- Keep your summary brief, no more than 3 minutes. ...
- Begin the discussion with an open question asking for reactions to the article. ...
- Ask one of your prepared questions. ...
- Should you run out of time before you go through all three questions, that is not a problem.
How do you lead a journal discussion?
Summarise the author’s conclusions. Say whether or not you find the paper convincing . If the audience has not chipped in by now, highlight points that your audience might want to discuss, or ask them questions about what they thought about particular aspects of the paper.
How do you start a journal club discussion?
- Make It a Routine. Schedule the journal club at a recurring time and location, so that it becomes a regular part of everyone’s schedule. ...
- Designate a Leader. ...
- Get Organized. ...
- Pre-Read Papers. ...
- Build a Community. ...
- Choose Relevant Papers. ...
- Make Engaging Presentations. ...
- Keep It Exciting.
How do you ask a question in a journal club?
- What is the most important result of the discussed paper?
- Is the result incremental with well-understood foundations in the area? ...
- Was the paper clearly written? ...
- What is the most interesting aspect of the paper? ...
- What is the most fundamental mathematical concept mentioned and used?
How do you discuss research articles?
A good discussion section includes analysis of any unexpected findings. This paragraph should begin with a description of the unexpected finding, followed by a brief interpretation as to why you believe it appeared and, if necessary, its possible significance in relation to the overall study.
What makes a good journal club?
Ask specific questions to the members of the journal club. ... Questions can be about methods, results, general ideas, and much more! Journal clubs are great forums for the exchange of thoughts and ideas . Clubs held at the NIH are just one way through which necessary scientific discussion and collaboration can take place.
Why is journal club important?
A journal club serves three purposes: teach and develop critical appraisal skills , increase exposure to rapidly evolving medical literature and help in informed clinical practice. They facilitate better knowledge and literature awareness through group discussion with peers.
What kinds of questions should you ask about these studies before accepting the findings as valid?
- What are the researchers’ hypotheses? ...
- What are the independent and dependent variables? ...
- What is the unit of analysis? ...
- How well does the study design address causation? ...
- What are the study’s results? ...
- How generalizable are the results?
What is an example of discussion?
An example of a discussion is when two or more people disagree and decide to sit down and talk out their different opinions . ... Conversation or debate concerning a particular topic. There was then a long discussion of whether to capitalize words like “east”. This topic is not open to discussion.
How do you write a discussion?
- Summarize the key findings in clear and concise language. ...
- Acknowledge when a hypothesis may be incorrect. ...
- Place your study within the context of previous studies. ...
- Discuss potential future research. ...
- Provide the reader with a “take-away” statement to end the manuscript.
How do you write a thesis discussion?
- Begin with a restatement of your research question, followed by a statement about whether or not, and how much, your findings “answer” the question. ...
- Relate your findings to the issues you raised in the introduction.
How do you present a medical journal article?
Start your article presentation with a brief case presentation , or briefly explain how the article is relevant to a patient or problem you are considering. This helps listeners more fully engage with your presentation and makes it more of a story.
Which activity occurs in a journal club?
A journal club is a regular gathering of scientists to discuss a scientific paper found in a research journal. One or two members of the club present a summary of the chosen paper that the whole group has read. Then, the discussion begins.
What is a Journal Club in pharmacy?
Linzer describes a journal club as “... a group of individuals who meet regularly to discuss critically the clinical applicability of articles in the current medical journals .” 2 Given that a journal club provides an excellent forum for keeping healthcare professionals abreast of literature pertaining to their practice, ...
How important is the role of the journal club facilitator?
The key role of Journal Club Facilitators is to encourage participation of staff nurses . Several strategies can be used to stimulate interest and enthusiasm among staff members. Try one or all of these methods. Be creative and come up with other ideas that best fit the culture on your unit.
