What does Carl Luce recommend to Holden? Carl Luce recommended that Holden go to a psychoanalyst .
What is Luce suggest Holden?
When Luce arrives, he treats Holden coolly, and Holden pesters him with questions about sex. Luce refuses to be drawn into the kind of sex discussion that they had had at Whooton, and he suggests that Holden needs psychoanalysis .
What does Holden want from Carl Luce?
What does Holden confide in Carl Luce?
What is the good thing Holden keeps saying about Carl Luce?
What did Luce suggest Holden should do at the end of Chapter 19?
After a while, Holden says the main problem with his sex life is that he can’t become intimate with a girl unless he actually likes her. In response, Luce says he should see a psychoanalyst .
What does Carl think Holden needs do you think Carl is right?
Do you think Carl is right? Carl thinks that Holden needs to go to a psychoanalyst , which is Carl’s to get him on his feet, and stop fooling around with his life.
How is Luce important to understanding Holden?
Holden still remembers the way Luce used to be able to identify whether or not a person was gay , a skill Holden found quite impressive even if he secretly thought that Luce himself might be gay. During one of his lonelier moments in New York, Holden decides to call Luce even though he doesn’t necessarily even like him.
What does Holden wonder about Luce?
What does Holden wonder about Luce? Holden tells Luce that something screws up his sex life . What is it? Holden says that his rule is when he likes a girl he does not do anything with her.
What is the one positive thing Holden says about Luce at the end of the chapter?
What is the one positive thing Holden says about Luce at the end of the chapter? Holden says that Luce has a good vocabulary ; he had the largest of any boy at Whooton.
What does Holden dislike about Carl?
What does Holden dislike about Carl Luce? What sorts of talks has he had in the past? Holden doesn’t like that Carl himself does flitty things . Holden makes the effort to see him because he’s running out of people to talk to and he’s desperate.
What is Luce referring to when he mentions typical Caulfield questions?
When Luce say ‘Typical Caulfield’ and this implies that Holden has not grown up since he last saw Luce, and still is maintaining immature and child social connection .
What are Holden’s suspicions about Luce?
Holden reveals that Luce is a pretty sexed-up character. At school, he used to always give the boys talks about sex. He always claimed that certain famous people were “flits” (gay), and Holden has his suspicions that Luce himself is gay .
Who tells Holden to grow up?
Society is simple. One does not get to choose when he/she grows up. Society tells him/her when to grow up. Society reveals to its children, when the proper time is to grow up.
Does Holden respect Luce?
Recognizing his confusion, Holden feels that he needs someone to help him understand adulthood, especially its sexuality, and thus he calls Luce. Holden respects Luce because he sees him as an intelligent adult.
What is one of the annoying things about Luce according to Holden?
Holden suspects Luce of being homosexual , and although he seems outwardly dismissive of homosexual men (e.g., using the derogatory word “flit”), later in this chapter Holden also seems to have fun looking for potentially homosexual men and pointing them out to Carl. “Hey, I got a flit for you,” I told him.
What does Holden realize at the end?
Why is Holden happy at the end?
What kinds of questions does Holden ask Carl?
Who is Carl Luce in Catcher in the Rye?
Carl Luce is Holden’s former student advisor from the Whooton School . He is three years older than Holden. At Whooton, Carl was a source of information about sex for the younger boys. When Holden is in New York City, he meets up with Carl, who is now nineteen and a student at Columbia.
What does Holden drink in wicker bar?
How does Carl feel about Holden?
Spencer. When they meet, however, Carl has little patience for Holden’s immature antics . And though he offers Holden sincere advice about seeking psychiatric help, this advice falls on deaf (and increasingly drunk) ears. Perhaps another reason Holden reaches out to Carl is that he suspects Carl might be gay.
How old is Holden Caulfield at the end of the book?
Is Holden in a mental hospital?
Holden is not specific about his location while he’s telling the story, but he makes it clear that he is undergoing treatment in a mental hospital or sanatorium . The events he narrates take place in the few days between the end of the fall school term and Christmas, when Holden is sixteen years old.
Does Holden Caulfield have a mental disorder?
Caulfield may be seen as suffering from a variety of mental illnesses including depression, anxiety, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) . This mental state could be a result of a variety of factors, including the death of his younger brother Allie, as well as witnessing the gruesome scene of a classmate’s death.
How is Luce important to understanding Holden?
Holden still remembers the way Luce used to be able to identify whether or not a person was gay , a skill Holden found quite impressive even if he secretly thought that Luce himself might be gay. During one of his lonelier moments in New York, Holden decides to call Luce even though he doesn’t necessarily even like him.
What does Holden wonder about Luce?
What are Holden’s suspicions about Luce?
Holden reveals that Luce is a pretty sexed-up character. At school, he used to always give the boys talks about sex. He always claimed that certain famous people were “flits” (gay), and Holden has his suspicions that Luce himself is gay .
