Is It Possible To Have Power But Not Legitimacy?

by | Last updated on January 24, 2024

, , , ,

Power is an entity's or individual's ability to control or direct others, while authority is influence that is predicated on perceived legitimacy. Consequently, power is necessary for authority, but it

is possible to have power without authority

. In other words, power is necessary but not sufficient for authority.

Contents hide

Does authority have to be legitimate?

The consent theory of political authority states only a necessary condition of the legitimacy of political authority. It states that a political authority

is legitimate only if it has the consent of those who are subject to its commands

.

How does power gain legitimacy?

In political science, legitimacy usually is understood as the popular acceptance and recognition by the public of the authority of a governing régime, whereby authority has political power through consent and mutual understandings, not coercion.

Can you have authority but not power how?

Yes,

it is possible for someone to have formal authority but no power

. This may occur if they are unable to exercise autonomy to make decisions or lead a specific group of people. Examples include “leaders” in puppet governments or leaders of true democracies.

What is legitimacy power?

Legitimate power is

the formal authority given to a person within an organization

. … Legitimate power is based on a person holding a particular position of authority within an organization. This gives them power over others and lets them make decisions within the broader system.

How is legitimacy related with authority?

Authority is the right of an individual to act on behalf of the government, while legitimacy is

the right of the government to act on behalf of society

.

Is there constitutional legitimacy for public administration?

public administration. the American Constitution in that their conduct and character were in part suspect. … The legitimacy of public administration is

to be found within the “logic” of a constitution

and not in the constitutional argument of the American founders.

How do you build legitimacy?

The logic of social action proposes three basic mechanisms for building legitimacy:

a logic of appropriateness

, based on following rules; a logic of consequences, based on self interest; and a logic of communicative action, based on argumentation (see Fig.

What is an example of legitimate power?

Legitimate power is power that comes from one's organizational role or position. For example,

a boss can assign projects

, a policeman can arrest a citizen, and a teacher assigns grades.

Why do we need legitimacy?

Legitimacy is

a crucial aspect of all power relations

. Without legitimacy, power is exerted through coercion; with legitimacy, power can be exerted through voluntary or quasi-voluntary compliance. … Legitimacy lies at the core of state-citizen relationships and thus of the whole state-building agenda.

What is charismatic legitimacy?

Charismatic authority is

power legitimized on the basis of a leader's exceptional personal qualities

, or the demonstration of extraordinary insight and accomplishment, which inspire loyalty and obedience from followers.

How do you exercise power?

  1. Add balance exercises. …
  2. Leg Press. …
  3. Medicine Ball Squat Throws. …
  4. Squat Jump. …
  5. Barbell Curl.

What is political legitimacy?

legitimacy,

popular acceptance of a government, political regime, or system of governance

. The word legitimacy can be interpreted in either a normative way or a “positive” (see positivism) way. … As such, legitimacy is a classic topic of political philosophy.

Who has define power as legitimate power?

Legitimate power is perhaps the most important basis of authority in any formal organization, such as a government agency or a corporation. Legitimate power is derived by way of

the manager's office and the organizational laws

and rules that define the scope of the office's power.

What are the three types of legitimate authority?

According to Max Weber, the three types of legitimate authority are

traditional, rational-legal, and charismatic

.

What is the difference between legitimate and coercive power?

Coercive power is defined as “harsh” power, as the capacity to detect and sanction unlawful behavior (Raven et al., 1998; Turner, 2005). Legitimate power is defined as “

soft” power

and refers to the power of position, expertise, dissemination of relevant information, and identification (Raven et al., 1998, cf.

What is legitimacy and examples?

Legitimacy is defined as the lawfulness or authenticity of something, or refers to

the status of a child being born to married parents

. … When a child is born to a mother and father who are married, this is an example of legitimacy.

Is it harder to frame a Constitution than run it?

In 1887, the centennial year of the American Constitution,

Woodrow Wilson

wrote that “it is getting to be harder to run a constitution than to frame one.” The context for Wilson's comment was an essay calling for sound principles of administration that would enable government officials to “run” a constitution well.

What is another word for legitimacy?

In this page you can discover 20 synonyms, antonyms, idiomatic expressions, and related words for legitimacy, like:

legitimateness

, authenticity, credibility, lawfulness, legality, licitness, law, genuineness, illegitimacy, sovereignty and neutrality.

What is legitimacy of the Constitution?

Constitutional legitimacy is a virtue rooted in a system of belief:

the acceptance that an exercise in power is justified and therefore authorized, either implicitly or explicitly, by society at large

. … This is in contrast to conventional lawmaking, where legal legitimacy is presumed.

What does the Constitution say about public administration?

195. (1) Public administration must be governed by the democratic values and principles enshrined in the Constitution, including the following principles: (a)

A high standard of professional ethics must be promoted and maintained

. (b) Efficient, economic and effective use of resources must be promoted.

What is government power?

In social science and politics, power is the capacity of an individual to influence the actions, beliefs, or conduct (behaviour) of others. The term authority is often used for power that is perceived as legitimate or socially approved by the social structure, not to be confused with authoritarianism.

What is sovereignty and legitimacy?

Sovereignty is

the supreme authority within a territory

. … In political theory, sovereignty is a substantive term designating supreme legitimate authority over some polity. In international law, sovereignty is the exercise of power by a state.

What are the responsibilities of the legitimate government?

That is, the government has a

legitimate RIGHT to enforce laws and collect taxes

, and we, the governed, have a legitimate DUTY or OBLIGATION to obey laws and pay taxes, etc.

Do all managers have legitimate power?

Legitimate. Legitimate power comes from holding a position of authority. Teachers, managers, heads of

state all derive power from position

. Those holding legitimate power are deemed to have the “right” to ask things of subordinates who, therefore, comply.

Does the President have legitimate power?

The office of the president can be best described under ‘legitimate power'. … The

president's power has everything to do with his title

. The president has his power because he is the President of the United States, not because he is Barack Obama, or whoever else is the current president.

What are the requirements of valid and effective legitimacy?

  • A child born before six months of a marriage is considered illegitimate. …
  • A child born after six months is legitimate. …
  • A child born after the dissolution of marriage is legitimate if he is born within 10 months as per Shia law or 2 years as per Hanafi Law.

In what ways can rulers claim legitimacy?

Legitimation is often done by

justifying the existence of rulers or their rules

in terms of important normative principles of the society. However, legitimation may also be attempted through payoffs and inducements to subordinates.

What is proof of legitimacy?

n. 1

any evidence that establishes or helps to establish the truth

, validity, quality, etc., of something. 2 (Law) the whole body of evidence upon which the verdict of a court is based.

When can we say that a government is legitimate?

A

government generally acknowledged as being in control of a nation and deserving formal recognition

, which is symbolized by the exchange of diplomats between that government and the governments of other countries.

Why is legitimacy important in leadership?

Legitimacy is important

for the achievement of development in a legitimate government

. Legitimacy itself is public acceptance and recognition of moral rights leaders to govern, create and implement political decisions.

What is the difference between power and authority?

Power is an entity's or individual's ability to control or direct others, while authority is influence that is predicated on perceived legitimacy. Consequently,

power is necessary for authority

, but it is possible to have power without authority. In other words, power is necessary but not sufficient for authority.

Is charismatic an authority?

The Charismatic authority is

an authority based on the special personal qualities claimed by and for an individual in order to make the person attractive

so that he could influence a large number of people. Originally, it is used in a religious context but now-a-days it is used in all spheres.

Is charisma a virtue?

Charisma is often described as

a virtue of leaders

. Even when a leader is immoral, his charismatic personality may be cited as a positive trait. Just as it would be a compliment to describe an immoral leader as handsome or intelligent, so too does charisma count in one's favor.

What is flexibility?

Flexibility is

the ability of a joint or series of joints to move through an unrestricted, pain free range of motion

. … The range of motion will be influenced by the mobility of the soft tissues that surround the joint. These soft tissues include: muscles, ligaments, tendons, joint capsules, and skin.

How can I increase my hand power?

  1. Hold a soft ball in your palm and squeeze it as hard as you can.
  2. Hold for a few seconds and release.
  3. Repeat 10 to 15 times on each hand. Do this exercise two to three times a week, but rest your hands for 48 hours in between sessions. Don't do this exercise if your thumb joint is damaged.

Do followers have other power bases besides referent and expert power?

Do followers have other power bases besides referent and expert power?

Followers have the same power bases as leaders

. … Giving them equal or greater power base. Other potential powers for followers, connection or relationships, coercive.

Who has coercive power?

Coercive power is the ability of

a manager to force an employee

to follow an order by threatening the employee with punishment if the employee does not comply with the order. The most important concept to understand about coercive power is that it uses the application of force.

Charlene Dyck
Author
Charlene Dyck
Charlene is a software developer and technology expert with a degree in computer science. She has worked for major tech companies and has a keen understanding of how computers and electronics work. Sarah is also an advocate for digital privacy and security.