First she gives the example of a Samurai trying
out his new sword by cutting someone else in half
. The moral isolationist would say that we can’t judge the Samurai because we are not living in medieval Japan. (Midgley, 25) Then Midgley says that if moral isolationism is right, other cultures can’t blame us either.
What is Midgley’s position regarding the samurai practice of trying out one’s new sword?
For example, Midgley mentions the ancient Japanese practice of a samurai trying out his new sword by
slicing a wayfarer
. While we might not live in Japan we are supposed to praise the samurai for his actions. A samurai must do such actions to honor himself as a samurai and not let down his emperor.
What does Midgley ultimately conclude about the bisecting Samurai quizlet?
What does Midgley ultimately conclude about the bisecting Samurai? a.
His action was morally good
. … We can put ourselves in a position to make a moral judgment about his actions if we overcome laziness, ignorance, and prejudice.
What is Midgley’s example of trying out one’s new sword intended to show?
What is Midgley’s example of “trying out one’s new sword” intended to show? Midgley’s example of “trying out one’s new sword” is intended to show
how difficult it is for us to understand a custom of a different culture using our own culture’s moral framework
.
What does Midgley mean by moral isolationism quizlet?
Moral Isolationism is according to Mary Midgely is to respect other cultures and not critize them. We can’t know another culture well enough to judge it. Disrespectful to judge what you don’t know. 2. Midgley says that
“moral isolationism would lay down a general ban on moral reasoning.”
What is moral reasoning?
What would a hedonist say about a person who sometimes enjoyed being humiliated or manipulated?
3. Hedonists respond to the Argument from Evil Pleasures by admitting that the pleasure that comes from doing evil deeds is not valuable. … A hedonist who sometimes enjoyed being humiliated and manipulated would say
these things would never be good for such a person.
What is moral isolationism?
Moral Isolationism is
the view that we can never understand any culture except our own, so we cannot make moral judgments about other cultures
. … According to Midgley, if moral isolationism is true, we can’t judge any culture without understanding that culture. (By “judge” she just means forming an opinion.
Why does Mary Midgley reject moral isolationism?
Midgley then argues that moral isolationism leads to
a general ban on moral reasoning
– an unpalatable conclusion. She says that judging one’s own culture requires the ability to judge other cultures, as a frame of reference. … Therefore, moral isolationism is false.
What mental picture of the moral isolationism is Midgley declare to be quite unreal?
The moral isolationist’s picture
of separate, unmixable cultures
is quite unreal. People who talk about British history usually stress the value of this fertilizing mix, no doubt rightly.
Is Mary Midgley a moral isolationist?
Mary Midgley’s essay is about
moral isolationism
, which is the view that we can never understand any culture except our own well enough to make judgments about it. For example, in the essay Midgley used, “a verb in classical Japanese which means ‘to try out one’s new sword on a chance wayfarer,’” (388, Midgley).
Which of the following are versions of moral skepticism?
Different versions of Moral Skepticism
deny or doubt moral knowledge
, justified moral belief, moral truth, moral facts or properties, and reasons to be moral: Pyrrhonian Moral Skepticism is content to merely doubt that moral knowledge is even possible.
How does Ruth Benedict define moral goodness?
Ruth Benedict (1887-1948), an anthropologist, argues that
science forces us to accept ethical relativism
. … Mankind has always preferred to say, “It is morally good,” rather than “It is habitual,” and the fact of this preference is matter enough for a critical science of ethics.
What is moral relativism simple?
Moral relativism is
the idea that there are no absolute rules to determine whether something is right or wrong
. … Moral relativists argue that there is more than one valid system of morality.
How does Midgley characterize moral isolationism?
How does Midgley characterize “moral isolationists”?
They believe we cannot criticize other cultures
. … The world is different from how your belief represents it.
What is moral isolationism quizlet?
STUDY
.
The view that one ought to respect other cultures but not judge them
.
What does Midgley mean by moral isolationism do you think moral isolationism is a widely held view in our society today?
Midgley argues that moral isolationism is
essentially a doctrine of immoralism because it forbids any moral reasonings
. … Furthermore, it falsely assumes that cultures are separate and unmixed, whereas most cultures are in face formed out of many influences.
