Longstreet had said precisely that, just hours before the assault, to Lee himself: “General,” he said, “
I have been a soldier all my life
. I have been with soldiers engaged in fights by couples, by squads, companies, regiments, divisions and armies, and should know, as well as any one, what soldiers can do.
Why did Lee and Longstreet disagree?
‘They
lacked the fire and point of his usual bearing on the battlefield
. ‘ Longstreet allowed his disagreement with Lee’s plans to affect his generalship, and he deserves censure for this. While he may have opposed the idea of an offensive, he was still in a position of responsibility.
What did General Lee say when overruled General Longstreet?
Lee and Longstreet concurred on what ‘the ruling idea of the campaign’ must be. In Longstreet’s words: ‘
Under no circumstances were we to give battle, but exhaust our skill in trying to force the enemy to do so in a position of our own choosing. The 1st Corps to receive the attack and fight the battle.
What does Longstreet think about the Confederate attempt to invade North?
He believed this
would entrench the Confederate army in a way that would make it necessary for the Union to attack the Confederate position
. Thus, the Confederates would be fighting a defensive battle, as Longstreet had hoped.
What did Pickett say about Lee?
Pickett’s division suffered staggering casualties during the attack, with nearly 50 percent of his men killed, captured or wounded, including all of his brigade commanders. When Lee later asked about the state of his division, a despondent Pickett is said to have answered,
“General Lee, I have no division.”
Why didn’t Meade pursue Lee?
Meade was reluctant to begin an immediate pursuit because
he was unsure whether Lee intended to attack again and his orders continued
that he was required to protect the cities of Baltimore and Washington, D.C. Since Meade believed that the Confederates had well fortified the South Mountain passes, he decided he would …
What did General Lee say at Appomattox?
“
I feel that it is so, and regard it as my duty to shift from myself any further effusion of blood, by asking of you the surrender of that portion of the C.S. Army known as the Army of Northern Virginia
.” Lee responded, saying he did not agree with Grant’s opinion of the hopelessness of further resistance of his army.
Did Pickett ever forgive Lee?
Pickett was inconsolable for the rest of the day and
never
forgave Lee for ordering the charge. When Lee told Pickett to rally his division for the defense, Pickett allegedly replied, “General, I have no division.” … History may never know the true story of Lee’s intentions at Gettysburg.
Why did Lee lose the Civil War?
The most convincing ‘internal’ factor behind southern defeat was the very institution that prompted secession:
slavery
. Enslaved people fled to join the Union army, depriving the South of labour and strengthening the North by more than 100,000 soldiers. Even so, slavery was not in itself the cause of defeat.
Could General Lee have won at Gettysburg?
Early extolled Lee’s genius. In fact, Early claimed,
Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia would have won the Battle
of Gettysburg, the turning point in the Civil War, if his orders had been obeyed. … But that sunrise attack, Early noted ominously, had never taken place.
How many Confederate soldiers were killed at Gettysburg?
Battle of Gettysburg: Aftermath and Impact
Though the cautious Meade would be criticized for not pursuing the enemy after Gettysburg, the battle was a crushing defeat for the Confederacy. Union casualties in the battle numbered 23,000, while the Confederates had lost
some 28,000 men
–more than a third of Lee’s army.
Was Longstreet a scalawag?
After the war, Longstreet joined the Republican Party and held several federal offices beginning in the Grant administration. Such actions earned him the moniker of
“scalawag” among his
fellow Southerners, nor did his postwar criticism of Robert E. Lee endear him to former Confederates.
Why was Pickett’s Charge a mistake?
Though Pickett received the majority of the blame for the blunder of the charge,
he was acting under orders from superior officers
. Often Longstreet is forgotten as the main player and orchestrator of the deadly charge. Longstreet later reflected on the mistakes made to Lieutenant Colonel Fremantle.
What was the Confederacy most important military victory?
The Battle of Chancellorsville
(April 30-May 6, 1863) was a huge victory for the Confederacy and General Robert E. Lee during the Civil War, though it is also famous for being the battle in which Confederate General Thomas “Stonewall” Jackson was mortally wounded.
What battle was the deadliest day in American history?
The deadliest single day battle in American history, if all engaged armies are considered, is
the Battle of Antietam
with 5,389 killed, including both United States and enemy soldiers (total casualties for both sided was 22,717 dead, wounded, or missing American and enemy soldiers September 17, 1862).
Was Pickett a good general?
He is best remembered for being one
of the commanders at Pickett’s Charge
, the futile and bloody Confederate offensive on the third day of the Battle of Gettysburg that bears his name. Pickett graduated last out of 59 cadets in the United States Military Academy class of 1846.
