Marx’s main argument is that
class is determined by economic factors alone
, whereas in contrast, Weber argues that social stratification cannot be defined solely in terms of class and the economic factors which affect class relationships.
The main difference between the two theories is that
Marx believed class relations to have their roots in exploitation and domination within production relations
— production is more central to Marx because of its ‘salience’ for the problem of exploitation (Wright, 1997), while Weber saw class positions as reflecting …
How did Karl Marx and Max Weber differ on their views of society?
Marx’s main argument is
that class is determined by economic factors alone
, whereas in contrast, Weber argues that social stratification cannot be defined solely in terms of class and the economic factors which affect class relationships.
Webers point of view was that he saw Social Stratification as
3 distinctive dimensions of inequality
. … and inequality. Differences between the two were that Marx saw it in a two class model capitalist and proletarians. Weber saw it as class, status and power.
What are the similarities and differences between Marx and Weber’s theory?
Both of them may share some similarity in the sense that they included economic condition as a factor, but the differ in the sense that
Marx believe in ‘historical materialism’ and argue that class relation of production is the sole determinant of the society
; Weber, on the opposite, reject Marx’s idea of economic …
Who is better Marx or Weber?
Weber
has more value in the sense that his methods of identifying class inequality are still very valid, but Marx’s writing on class is generally a much stronger and more accurate theory.
What did Max Weber and Karl Marx agree on?
Max Weber was a German sociologist who agreed with Marx
that people often fight to protect their own interests
, but he agreed with Durkheim that what people consider their interests often are determined by socialization and shared values. He believed society is becoming more rationalized and bureaucratic over time.
Karl Marx was very interested in class relations in capitalist societies. Class was determined solely by one’s relation to the means of production. For Marx, class was determined
solely by the relationship of a group to the means of production
.
What did Karl Marx mean by class struggle?
Definition. Class struggle happens when the bourgeoisie (the rich) pay the proletariat (the workers) to make things for them to sell. The workers have no say in their pay or what things they make, since they cannot live without a job or money. Karl Marx saw that the workers had to work without any say in the business.
Class, for Marx, is defined as
a (social) relationship rather than a position or rank in society
. … The structure and basis of a social class may be defined in objective terms, as groups with a common position with respect to property or the means of production.
What is Weber’s sociological theory?
Weber’s primary focus
on the structure of society lay in the elements of class, status, and power
. Similar to Marx, Weber saw class as economically determined. … Both status and class determined an individual’s power, or influence over ideas. Unlike Marx, Weber believed that these ideas formed the base of society.
What is the difference between Max Weber and Marx on the concept of power?
Marx also
exaggerates the importance of economic power
, and fails to consider other possible sources of power such as political power. In contrast Weber emphasises the role of political power and generalises it to economic power.
What is Karl Marx’s theory?
Marxism is
a social, political, and economic theory
originated by Karl Marx, which focuses on the struggle between capitalists and the working class. … He believed that this conflict would ultimately lead to a revolution in which the working class would overthrow the capitalist class and seize control of the economy.
What does Karl Marx say about inequality?
Marxists theorize that inequality and poverty are functional components of the capitalist mode of production: capitalism necessarily produces inegalitarian social structures.
Inequality is transferred from one generation to another through the environment of services and opportunities which surrounds each individual
.
In Marx’s view,
social stratification is created by people’s differing relationship to the means of production: either they own productive property or they labor for others
. In Marxist theory, the capitalist mode of production consists of two main economic parts: the substructure and the Superstructure.
What does Max Weber say about inequality?
Weber said that
inequality is more complex than what Marx described
. He defined power as being the ability to influence others to do your will and claimed that power had a number of sources such as ownership of land and capital, social status, physical strength and education.
