What Should I Look For When Reviewing A Paper?

• Introduction: Mirror the article, state your expertise and whether the paper is publishable, or whether there are fatal flaws;
• Major flaws;
• Minor flaws;
• Other, lesser suggestions and final comments.

What is something you should look for when reviewing a paper?

• Check the journal’s aims and scope. …
• Define your scope. …
• Finding sources to evaluate. …
• Writing your title, abstract and keywords. …
• Introduce the topic. …
• Include critical discussion. …
• Sum it up. …
• Use a critical friend.

What should I look for when reviewing research?

Writing

a good review requires expertise in the field, an intimate knowledge of research methods, a critical mind, the ability to give fair and constructive feedback, and sensitivity to the feelings of authors on the receiving end.

How do I choose a reviewer for my paper?

1. Check the references in the article. …
2. Use search tools and databases to find researchers working on similar topics. …
3. Use your editorial board. …
4. Consider previous authors and guest editors. …
5. Ask reviewers who decline for suggestions. …
6. Use predefined keywords. …
7. Use previous reviewers.

How do you review a paper?

1. Don’t start your review when you are not in a good mood.
2. Be responsible and do it in time. …
3. Try to write in a simple and clear English. …
4. Be open to new ideas and don’t try to take the author to what you want. …
5. Complicated papers are not necessarily of good quality.

What is the format of a review?

Provide a brief

summary

of the review question being addressed or rationale for the review, the major studies reviewed, and conclusions drawn. Please do not cite references in the Abstract. Introduction: Introduce the topic and your rationale for addressing this topic focusing on why this topic is important.

How do you write a review example?

1. Step 1: Write the Title. First of all, you need to write a title that reflects the main focus of your work. …
2. Step 2: Cite the Article. …
3. Step 3: Article Identification. …
4. Step 4: Introduction. …
5. Step 5: Summarize the Article. …
6. Step 6: Critique It. …
7. Step 7: Craft a Conclusion.

What are some weaknesses of an article?

Identifying six major weaknesses Inadequate or unfocused topic sentences.

Writing off-subject

. Failing to anticipate objections. An inadequate conclusion.

How do you start a review?

1. Introduce your topic. It may sound redundant to “introduce” your topic in the introduction, but often times writer’s fail to do so. …
2. State your topic’s relevance. …
3. Reveal your thesis to the reader.

How will you know if an article can be included in your literature review?

The literature review section of an article is a

summary or analysis of all the research the author read before doing his

/her own research. This section may be part of the introduction or in a section called Background.

How many suggested reviewers are there?

Most papers are reviewed by

2-3 reviewers

, but to have the 2-3 reviewers available, more potential reviewers have to be contacted because not all invited reviewers will respond or will be available to review the paper. Therefore, journals ask you for 3-6 suggestions.

How can you tell if something is peer reviewed?

If the article is from a printed journal, look at the publication information in the front of the journal. If the article is from an electronic journal, go

to the journal home page

and look for a link to ‘About this journal’ or ‘Notes for Authors’. Here it should tell you if the articles are peer-reviewed.

What is a preferred reviewer?

So it is always better to give a list of preferred reviewers. Your choice of preferred reviewers should

never

be random. When a journal wants you to suggest reviewers, they want a list of relevant people who would be able to provide objective and constructive criticism of your paper.

How do you approach reading a paper?

1. Begin by reading the introduction, not the abstract. …
2. Identify the big question. …
3. Summarize the background in five sentences or less. …
4. Identify the specific question(s). …
5. Identify the approach. …
6. Read the methods section. …
7. Read the results section.

How do you write a good peer review?

1. Do Be Kind. The basic premise of peer review is to encourage further writing. …
2. Do Give Concrete Advice. Be specific with your feedback. …
3. Seek Support: Don’t Assume. …
4. Be Scientific: Don’t Ignore the Details. …
5. Do Meet the Deadlines.

How do you write a reviewer comment?

1. Justify your recommendation with concrete evidence and specific examples.
2. Be specific so the authors know what they need to do to improve.
3. Be thorough. This might be the only time you read the manuscript.
4. Be professional and respectful. …
5. Remember to say what you liked about the manuscript!