This story shows
the parallelism between what different immigrants think of moving to the United States from their home country
. Some embrace the change and are excited to adopt new cultures, while others are scared and wish to hang on to their culture.
What is Mukherjee's thesis glossary thesis?
Mukherjee's thesis is that
experiences as an immigrant in America can differ greatly from one person to another
. She states her thesis most explicitly in paragraph 11, when she writes, “In one family, from two sisters alike as peas in a pod, there could not be a wider divergence of immigrant experience.” (pg 406)
What metaphor does Mukherjee use to describe her approach to belonging to America how is it fitting?
Mukherjee brings in a metaphor to further describe the two different ways to exist as an immigrant in America. Mukherjee first uses the
literal example of either marrying or not marrying ones country
as she speaks of her own marriage to an American citizen and her sister's marriage to an Indian.
What basis for comparison exists between Mukherjee and her sister?
The basis of comparison for the two is established immediately in the essay;
both sisters have lived in the US for the same amount of time
.
What is Mukherjee's thesis and where does she present it?
What is Mukherjee's thesis? Where does she present it? -This is
a tale of two sisters from Calcutta, Mira and Bharati
, who lived in the United States for some thirty years, but who find themselves on different sides in the current debate over the status of immigrants.
What is Mukherjee's purpose is she trying to inform to move readers to action to accomplish something else explain?
To accomplish something else? Explain. Mukherjee's purpose is to inform;
she likely wants her audience to reconsider their own perspective on immigration
.
Bharati Mukherjee wrote Two ways to belong in America
to respond to congress after taking away benefits from all immigrants
. This story told us the life of two Indians girls who left their country seeking a better future in the United States.
What country are the two sisters from two ways to belong in America from?
This is a tale of two sisters from
Calcutta
, Mira and Bharati, who have lived in the United States for some 35 years, but who find themselves on different sides in the current debate over the status of immigrants.
Do you think Mukherjee respects her sisters decision?
It seems as if Mukherjee did not originally respect her sister's decision but
grew to respect it over time
, especially after public opinion and legislation surrounding immigration began to change. … Neither type of immigration is more valid than the other.
How effective is Mukherjee's conclusion does it summarize the essay's major points would another strategy be more effective explain?
Mukherjee's conclusion is
quite effective
. She is letting the reader know that despite how these experiences differ, they still ultimately come with the same cost. To stay in America, an immigrant must change themselves in one way or another in order to fit in comfortably.
What points does Mukherjee discuss for each subject?
The points Mukherjee discusses include:
each sister's marriage, each sister's views on her Indian heritage
, whether or not to become an American citizen, and the choice to embrace American culture.
What is the difference between Bharati and Mira in terms of living in the USA?
Mira got married to a fellow Indian immigrant student while Bharati married a Canadian-American novelist. … According to Bharita, the difference between her and Mira is that whereas
her sister is an expatriate Indian living in America
, in contrast, she is an Indian immigrant who has acquired American citizenship.
What is Bharati Mukherjee two ways belong to America about?
Bharati argues the two ways to belong in America are
to transform yourself as an immigrant, or to be an exile
. Her sister, Mira, hangs on passionately to her Indian lifestyle and hopes return home to retire.
