In order to analyze simple and complex arguments, we will find it useful to
construct a diagram of the structure of the argument
that details the relations among the various premises and conclusions. … The number of arguments in a passage is conventionally established by the number of conclusions in that passage.
Why do we diagram arguments?
Argument Diagramming provides
an introduction to exploring and understanding arguments by explaining what the parts of an argument
are, and how to break arguments into their parts and create diagrams to show how those parts relate to each other.
What does it mean to diagram an argument?
An argument map or argument diagram is
a visual representation of the structure of an argument
. … The purpose of mapping is to uncover the logical structure of arguments, identify unstated assumptions, evaluate the support an argument offers for a conclusion, and aid understanding of debates.
Why is it important to construct an argument?
Argument helps us learn to clarify our thoughts and articulate them honestly and accurately and to consider the ideas of others in a respectful and critical manner. The purpose of argument is
to change people’s points of view
or to persuade people to a particular action or behavior.
What is the purpose of argument mapping?
Argument mapping is
a visual method of displaying how reasons work to support a claim
. A map exposes the hidden structure of the argument so that everyone can see how all the reasons fit together. You can map objections to any premise, so you can see exactly where two people disagree.
How do you standardize an argument?
- Standardization – restating an argument in standard logical form.
- An argument is said to be in standard logical form when each step in the argument is numbered consecutively, premises are stated above the conclusions they are claimed to support, and justifications are provided for each conclusion in the argument.
How do you evaluate an argument?
Put the argument in standard form. Decide if the argument is deductive or non-deductive. Determine whether the
argument succeeds
logically. If the argument succeeds logically, assess whether the premises are true.
Do all valid arguments have true premises?
TRUE:
A valid argument cannot have all true premises
and a false conclusion. So if a valid argument does have a false conclusion, it cannot have all true premises. Thus at least one premise must be false. … If an invalid argument has all true premises, then the conclusion must be false.
What is the first step in evaluating an argument?
The first step of evaluating an argument is
making an inference connection
. The second step is asserting premise acceptability. Two questions to ask first is (1) Is this argument valid and (2) is this argument sound or unsound.
What are the arguments?
1a : the
act or process of arguing, reasoning
, or discussing : argumentation. b : a coherent series of reasons, statements, or facts intended to support or establish a point of view a defense attorney’s closing argument. c : an angry quarrel or disagreement having an argument over/about money trying to settle an …
What is the strongest argument?
Definition: A strong argument is a
non-deductive argument that succeeds in providing probable
, but not conclusive, logical support for its conclusion. A weak argument is a non-deductive argument that fails to provide probable support for its conclusion.
What are the qualities of a good argument?
- Relevant. Revelant information is explored within the argument.
- Conclusion. The argument must be relevant to the conclusion.
- Believable. It must be believable.
- Focused. A good argument stays focused.
- Logically consistent. It is logically consistent.
- Contains claims.
How do you improve arguments?
- Stay calm. …
- Use facts as evidence for your position. …
- Ask questions. …
- Use logic. …
- Appeal to higher values. …
- Listen carefully. …
- Be prepared to concede a good point. …
- Study your opponent.
What is the difference between assumption and conclusion?
Assumptions are the unstated information needed to be valid for the conclusion to hold true. On the other hand, conclusions are made based on the assumptions given, so conclusion
needs to agree with
the given assumptions. … The conclusion must be based on the given premise/s.
What is a simple argument?
A simple argument is
just a contention with a single reason for it, OR a contention with a single objection to it
. Here are two simple arguments: Examples. The simple argument is the whole structure (reason AND contention). This is another simple argument, made up of an objection to a contention.
What are the basic elements included in argument mapping?
An argument map typically includes the key components of the argument, traditionally called
the conclusion and the premises, also called contention and reasons
. Argument maps can also show co-premises, objections, counterarguments, rebuttals, and lemmas.
