Can you have legitimacy but not authority?
Some authors have argued that legitimacy without authority is possible
, though their work has not found much uptake in mainstream political philosophy.
In political science,
legitimacy is the right and acceptance of an authority
, usually a governing law or a regime. Whereas authority denotes a specific position in an established government, the term legitimacy denotes a system of government—wherein government denotes “sphere of influence”.
A law has legitimacy when others feel obligated to obey it
. A legitimate authority is one which is entitled to have its decisions and rules accepted and followed by others.
Is it possible to have power but not legitimacy?
Power but not legitimacy?
Yes
; powerful peole can take control w/out the people agreeing (through threat, bribe, etc.)
What is legitimate power?
Legitimate power is the formal authority given to a person within an organization
. Because it comes from a position or job title, legitimate power is a form of positional power.
What is an example of legitimacy?
When a child is born to a mother and father who are married
, this is an example of legitimacy. The quality of being legitimate or valid; validity.
Authority is a formal title or position that gives someone the tools to influence other people within their organization. A person in authority is often powerful, but
power is not necessary for authority
.
How do you define legitimacy?
Legitimacy is commonly defined in political science and sociology as
the belief that a rule, institution, or leader has the right to govern
. It is a judgment by an individual about the rightfulness of a hierarchy between rule or ruler and its subject and about the subordinate’s obligations toward the rule or ruler.
Legitimacy is a crucial aspect of all power relations
. Without legitimacy, power is exerted through coercion; with legitimacy, power can be exerted through voluntary or quasi-voluntary compliance.
There can be indeed legitimate politics, which fall within the guidelines of what can be or could be considered normal or acceptable in the business world, or illegitimate politics, which is when someone cannot get what they want by any other, more acceptable means.
Who has legitimate power?
Legitimate power comes from having a position of power in an organization, such as being
the boss or a key member of a leadership team
. This power comes when employees in the organization recognize the authority of the individual.
Key Differences Between Power and Authority
Power is defined as the ability or potential of an individual to influence others and control their actions.
Authority is the legal and formal right to give orders and commands, and take decisions.
Power refers to the ability to have one’s will carried out despite the resistance of others. According to Max Weber, the three types of legitimate authority are
traditional, rational-legal, and charismatic
.
What is another word for legitimacy?
OTHER WORDS FOR legitimacy
lawfulness, legality, rightfulness
.
What makes a law legitimate?
The first, and often most important, factor in determining a government action’s legitimacy is its legality. For an action to be legitimized as legal,
it must have a valid legal pedigree
. That is, it must be authorized by a law that itself originates from a widely accepted source of law.
What is proof of legitimacy?
1
any evidence that establishes or helps to establish the truth, validity, quality, etc., of something
. 2 (Law) the whole body of evidence upon which the verdict of a court is based.
Examples are
bullying, stealing, and peer pressure
.
Legitimate authority (sometimes just called authority), Weber said, is power whose use is considered just and appropriate by those over whom the power is exercised. In short,
if a society approves of the exercise of power in a particular way, then that power is also legitimate authority
.
Authority is also necessary for leadership
. Because of their decisiveness, accomplishment track record, influence, courage, and inspiration, great leaders are able to help their teams accomplish great things. Great leaders may have power, but they are more likely to hold it in reserve and rely on authority to lead.
Which of the following best describes legitimacy?
rightful authority
. (ii) De facto power is always legitimate.
How do I change my illegitimate to legitimate?
Legitimation, or raising the status of the child from illegitimate to legitimate, occurs when the parents, later on, entered into a valid marriage. An illegitimate child may also become legitimate
through the process of adoption, i.e. the parent shall adopt his or her illegitimate child
.
What is legitimacy and its types?
According to one usage of the term, a government is said to be ‘legitimate’ if the people to whom its orders are directed believe that the structure, procedures, acts, decisions, policies, officials, or leaders or government possess the quality of Tightness, propriety or moral goodness—the right, in short, to make …
How and when can we say that power is legitimate?
Thus, legitimate power is defined by
formal and informal rules established by a rightfully elected government (power of position), and by their knowledge about skillful procedures (power of expertise)
.
What is legitimate power and examples?
Legitimate power is
power that comes from one’s organizational role or position
. For example, a boss can assign projects, a policeman can arrest a citizen, and a teacher assigns grades.
What is legitimate power in government?
Legitimate power is
power you derive from your formal position or office held in the organization’s hierarchy of authority
. For example, the president of a corporation has certain powers because of the office he holds in the corporation.
Do all managers have legitimate power?
Legitimate power stems from the manager’s position in the organization and the authority that lies in that position
. Subordinates acknowledge the legitimate power that comes from being in a leadership position in an organization. Reward power is the extent to which a manager can use rewards to influence others.
Definition of authority
1a :
power to influence or command thought, opinion, or behavior
the president’s authority. b : freedom granted by one in authority : right Who gave you the authority to do as you wish? 2a : persons in command specifically : government the local authorities of each state.
It is nothing but the liability created for the transfer of authority. Accountability
creates the obligation of the subordinate and makes him answerable for the work done by him/her
. Hence, it is the answerability for the performance of the assigned duties.
- Founder authority. Founder authority is usually held by the founding member of a group or organization. …
- Ownership authority. …
- Punitive authority. …
- Relational authority. …
- Reward authority. …
- Results authority. …
- Expert authority. …
- Reverent authority.
Weber defines authority as
legitimate forms of domination
, that is, forms of domination which followers or subordinates consider to be legitimate. Legitimate does not necessarily imply any sense of rationality, right, or natural justice.
Weber’s keen insight lay in distinguishing different types of legitimate authority that characterize different types of societies, especially as they evolve from simple to more complex societies. He called these three types
traditional authority, rational-legal authority, and charismatic authority
.
