- Begin by thanking the reviewer for taking the time to assess your manuscript.
- Then, specify that you’ve addressed all the concerns they raised. …
- List all the reviewer’s comments and your answer to each one. …
- Avoid giving yes or no answers.
How do you comment as a reviewer?
Avoid overly
negative wording or personal comments, point out the main strengths of the manuscript as well as its weaknesses, and suggest specific ways to fix the problems you identify. Also, avoid making overly brief and direct comments, as these can give your report an unfriendly tone.
How do you respond to a revision request?
- 1) Understand What the Journal Wants. …
- 2) Ask Why. …
- 3) Don’t Take the Revision Requests Personally. …
- 4) Tackle the Requests Soon But Not Immediately. …
- 5) Create your Checklist. …
- 6) Get Professional Scientific Editing Services. …
- 7) Check your Citations.
How do you say thank you to reviewer?
- “This review made our day!”
- “Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this amazing review.”
- “We are so grateful for your kind words. Thanks for sharing your review with us and the community.”
Is revise and resubmit good?
Authors should view an invitation to revise and resubmit as
good news
because it means the journal has found value with the article. If authors make a considered effort to address reviewers’ comments, then in all proba- bility, the resubmitted article will be accepted for publication.
Can a paper be rejected after major revision?
Yes your paper does have a chance to be accepted
. If it didn’t, you would not have gotten a major revision, but rather a rejection. Note the editor can choose to accept a paper even if the reviewers recommend rejection. It doesn’t happen often, but it’s possible.
How do you respond to a review example?
- Hi [Name], Thanks so much for your feedback! …
- Hi [Name] We can’t thank you enough for the kind words about [product/service]. …
- Hi [Name], Wow, we were blown away by your positive words, we really appreciate the time you took to write such a detailed review! …
- Dear [Name],
How do you thank someone for peer review?
Dear (reviewer name), I want to thank you for your review of {Title} {ID#}, submitted to UC Agriculture and Natural Resources. After careful consideration of your comments and those of the other reviewers, this submission has been {decision}. I greatly appreciate the time and commitment that goes into each review.
How do you respond to a reviewer letter?
- Begin by thanking the reviewer for taking the time to assess your manuscript.
- Then, specify that you’ve addressed all the concerns they raised. …
- List all the reviewer’s comments and your answer to each one. …
- Avoid giving yes or no answers.
How often are revise and resubmit accepted?
For journals I have managed, the number of “major revision” papers that are eventually accepted stays solidly
between 80-90%
. When editors, reviewers, and authors have put time into critiquing and improving a paper, it just seems downright unfair to reject the paper.
Does major revision mean rejection?
Minor revisions – Typically, this is the best outcome after first submission. Major revisions –
OK, you’ve got more work to do, but you’re still in the game
. Reject – Obviously, this isn’t good; but it may come with comments on how you can improve.
How long should a revise and resubmit take?
After the initial cycle, the “ball is back in the authors’ court” for a revision. On average, authors took
about 11 weeks
to resubmit, nearly as long as HSR took to get reviews.
Does major revision mean accepted?
To my experience, major revision in general
leads to the acceptance of a manuscript reviewed and re-reviewed for several rounds
. Minor revision may undergo referee evaluation; however, in most cases, the editor accepts the paper without sending the revised manuscript to the reviewer.
What are the chances of paper acceptance after major revision?
The probability of major revised paper is
more than 50%
. If one addresses the reviewers/editors comment properly, the paper acceptance chance is more. A very few papers rejected after revisions.
How long does a major revision take?
Most journals normally take
4-8 weeks to review manuscripts
. The ‘decision in process’ status implies that your manuscript has passed through peer review and the editorial board is now making a decision. In this step, the editor carefully evaluates all the comments by the peer-reviewers and examines the manuscript.
