How Do You Write An Academic Referee Report?

1. Address the letter.
2. Include a brief introduction.
3. Outline the student’s qualifications.
4. Describe a time that the student impressed you.
5. End the letter with a particular endorsement.
6. Provide your contact information.

How do you write a referee report?

1. send your report on or before the agreed deadline.
2. keep the journal informed about the progress of the report.
3. follow the instructions sent from the journal.
4. contact the journal if you have any questions.
5. give examples to make your meaning clear.

What should a referee report include?

The first section of the report (often one paragraph) should contain

a concise summary of the paper’s claimed results, contributions, and general line of reasoning

. The editor is typically not an expert in the paper’s subfield, so it is important for this summary to be clear.

What is an academic referee report?

As a referee you should be able to comment on the applicant’s research expertise and potential. This report is

to provide information on the applicant’s eligibility and readiness for a research degree at Deakin University

. In the case of scholarship applicants, this information will assist in their ranking.

What are the different ways to ensure positive comments from referee?

Start by listing out the significance and positive aspects of the manuscript and then indicate what can be improved.

Comment on large issues first

and go on to smaller issues later. Write vague, general comments without clear instructions of what should be changed.

How long should a referee report be?

The length of this report should be

between 2 or 3 pages of typed text

, 12 pt font, and 1.5 line spacing. 2) A letter to the editor with a recommendation on whether the paper should be published. The recommendation should be briefly justified (the length of the letter should be between 10 and 15 lines of typed text).

How do you respond to a referee report?

Just begin with something like this: “Thank you for the opportunity to revise my paper. I have commented below on each of the points raised by the referees.” Please respond to all of the major points made by the referees. Just saying “We have done what the referees asked” is insufficient.

Can a family member be a referee?

Hiring managers generally assume your parents can’t give an objective view of your work history or how you’ll behave as an employee, so don’t put them down as references. That goes for all family members, as they will most likely think you’re pretty great, Banul says.

Who can be academic referees?

A referee should be

someone you’re familiar with who can reflect on your academic and personal qualities

well. In most cases, your references will be written by academics from your undergraduate course such as your personal tutor or dissertation supervisor.

How do you get an academic referee?

1. Think about your college lecturers and who can vouch for your skills.
2. Ask your preferred referees before making any applications.
3. Give your referees the information they need to write a strong reference.

How do you write a reviewer comment?

1. Justify your recommendation with concrete evidence and specific examples.
2. Be specific so the authors know what they need to do to improve.
3. Be thorough. This might be the only time you read the manuscript.
4. Be professional and respectful. …
5. Remember to say what you liked about the manuscript!

What is a referee report?

Referee reports are

an assessment method where supervisors or other people with direct personal knowledge of an

applicant’s skills, knowledge and/or experience are asked to provide information on their performance against the selection criteria of the advertised vacancy.

What does it mean to referee a journal?

When one submits a paper describing one’s research to a scientific journal (at least the reputable ones), the editor chooses one or more scientists expert in the field to review or “

referee”

your paper.

How do you reference a math paper?

You can adapt this to the style of the journal in which your citation is to appear, but the key items of information should all be there: author’s name(s), year and month of publication, title, journal name and volume number, retrieval date, and exact URL.

How do you referee an economics paper?

The two purposes of the report is to

summarize a given paper

, and offer comments or suggestions to help an author improve the paper. Each report should have around 3 pages. Overall, don’t be afraid to have strong opinions (and perhaps be wrong), but be precise throughout.

What is the role of a referee while evaluating a thesis and a research paper?

Your role as referee is

to decide whether a paper makes a sufficient contribution to the field

. … As a referee, on the other hand, you must read the paper carefully and with an open mind, checking and evaluating the material with no presumption as to its quality or accuracy.