Antigone on the other hand was
more right than wrong
. Antigone, even though she was violating the human law made by Creon
Did Antigone do the right thing?
Antigone had good reasons for her actions.
She did obey the rules of her gods
, which were that any dead body must be given a proper burial, with libatations. This would prevent the soul from being lost between worlds forever, along with wine as an offering to the gods (page 518- side note).
Who is right Antigone or Creon in the play Antigone Why?
With her values and her loyalty to the individual,
Antigone
is the one who overall wins my side and sympathy over Creon. Antigone deals with the downfall of humans caused by their hubris and the errors they commit throughout the story.
Is Antigone ethical?
Antigone’s name bears within itself the fruits of her destiny. … She is
an ethical and religious character
because she acts according to her own nature and is committed to following what her personal fate requires her to do.
Why is Antigone a flawed character?
Antigone
believes her flaw to be her strength
; although her strength may be seen as a flaw, this is not what brought her to her untimely death. Antigone’s major flaw was her loyalty, and her commitment was what brought her to the afterlife.
Is Creon right or wrong?
There has been much debate about whether Antigone and Creon took the right decisions. According to Waldock in his essay, Romantic Tragedy: The Antigone, he has stated that there is no question that Antigones action is the right one and
that Creon’s is the wrong one
.
Why is Antigone right?
The fact is, Antigone did the right thing.
She was acting out of divine influence so to speak
. Since divinity and humanity are shown to be colliding forces where divinity out weighs humanity in ancient Greece. Antigone was justified in her actions.
What makes Creon a bad person?
Creon’s
tragic flaw, hubris, causes his downfall
. Creon will not listen to anyone. He is stubborn and his pride is so great, he can not bring himself to acknowledge that he could ever wrong. When Creon is talking to Teiresias, he thinks that he is being paid off.
What is ethical tragedy?
Ethics of Tragedy is
a profound analysis of Greek tragedies
, especially refugee tragedies and Sophocles’ Oedipus-trilogy, that presents the sense of tragedy in a time of rapacious capitalism and ecocatastrophe. … Instead of justifying the existing political order, tragedy disrupts, dissents, and exceeds it.
What is a moral tragedy?
A moral tragedy occurs
when, all things considered, every
.
viable option one is confronted with involves a serious moral violation
.
What was Antigone’s greatest mistake?
Creon’s
refusal to admit to his initial error
is his greatest mistake and act of stupidity.
Who is the true tragic hero of Antigone?
Creon
What did Antigone do wrong?
Antigone is
too proud to let her brother’s body be eaten and destroyed by the dogs and by the vultures
. As a result, she goes against the very strict law that Creon
What is the conflict between Antigone and Creon over?
The main source of conflict between Antigone and Creon is
the issue of the burial of Antigone’s dead brother
. Both of her brothers were killed in battle, however one brother fought against their home city and was considered a traitor. Creon issued a law that whoever tries to bury this man will be put to death.
Why does Antigone believe she is right to challenge Creon’s rule?
She wants to challenge Creon’s law head-on. … Antigone says that
Creon’s law was not the law of the gods of the underworld
—the gods of death and burial whose laws form unwritten, ancient traditions. She was not going to break the laws of the gods to appease a man.
What is Creon’s argument?
Creon’s argument:
Creon wants to lead by example and obey his law
, and he does not want to look weak or like there is favoritism for his family. Creon believes that that king must always be obeyed, and that only people who obey can be honored and trusted.
