What Is A Substitute For Caerphilly Cheese?

What Is A Substitute For Caerphilly Cheese? If you’re unable to find Caerphilly, a young, creamy English cheddar can serve as a substitute in recipes. What is a good substitute for Cantal cheese? Cantal is a semi-firm cheese with a slight grassy flavor when aged. English farmhouse cheddar or sharp white cheddar are fine substitutes.