What Do New Yorkers Call Hoagies?

by | Last updated on January 24, 2024

, , , ,


A submarine sandwich

, commonly known as a sub (North American English), hoagie (Mid-Atlantic and Western Pennsylvania English), hero (New York City English), Italian sandwich (Maine English) or grinder (New England English), is a type of cold or hot sandwich made from a cylindrical bread roll split lengthwise and …

Why do New Yorkers call subs heroes?

Head over to New York City, and you’ll see a similar sandwich referred to as a “hero.” The term likely comes from New York Herald Tribune columnist Clementine Paddleworth (yes, that was her name), who in 1936 described a sandwich so large “you had to be a hero to eat it.” More so than a sub,

a hero can refer to both

What do they call hoagies in New York?

While Philadelphians might bristle at anyone confusing a “hoagie” with a

“hero

” (the latter is a distinctly New York term), the connection between a “hoagie” and a “sub” is clear: They’re made with a variety of meat, cheese and toppings on loaves of French or Italian bread, usually served cold.

Do New Yorkers say hoagies?

Hoagie – Philadelphians call these sandwiches after a shipyard called Hog Island or the word Italian Americans used to call the scraps deli owners used to give to the poor. … Hero – New Yorkers have a more honorific name for their long rolled menu items.

What is a hoagie called in Philadelphia?

In 1950, a letter to the New York Times from a tourist to Philadelphia from Baltimore noted that the sandwich he recognized as a grinder was being referred to as a hoagie,

hoggy, horgy, or hogy

. These alternative names give some clues to the hoagie’s still-mysterious origins.

Why are they called hoagies?

Hoagie, a submarine sandwich filled with Italian meats, cheeses, and other toppings. The name likely comes from the Philadelphia area where, during World War I,

Italian immigrants who worked at the Hog Island shipyard began making sandwiches

; they were originally called “hoggies” before the name hoagie took hold.

What is a Spuckie?

The spuckie sandwich is how Bostonians call their

local variety of the Italian sandwich

. The spuckie is built inside a long and pointed Italian bread roll called spucadella. It’s made with cured meat, sliced cheese, fresh salad, and olive oil or vinaigrette.

Why is a sub called a grinder?

Subs, with their Italian bread and piles of fixings, were harder to chew through than your typical ham and cheese on white bread. That toothsomeness got translated into “grinder,” since that’s

what your teeth had to do to get through a bite

.

What’s the difference between a sub and a hoagie?

With a sub, the bread is a softer roll cut all the way through and

the top is separated from the bottom of the roll

. With a hoagie, a harder roll is preferred and the roll is split and the contents (generally the same) are stuffed into the roll and folded closed at the completion.

What’s the difference between a hoagie and a hero?

It’s “subs” in North Jersey,

“hoagies” in South Jersey

, “heroes” if you’re originally from New York City, “grinders” if you’re from New England. …

Do New Yorkers say sub or hero?

Indeed,

the word hero is

not unique to New York, but its usage is a little bit different in the Empire State. New Yorkers head to the deli for lunch to grab a hero—aka “a long sandwich made on a small loaf of bread or long roll that’s been cut in half lengthwise.” Maybe you call it a hoagie, a sub, or a grinder?

What is the longest sandwich ever made?

According to the Guinness Book of World Records, the largest sandwich ever made was in 2005 in the United States and weighed 5,440 kg (11,993 lb), while the honor of the longest sandwich goes to Lebanon with a sandwich

over 7.5 meters (2,411 feet) long

in 2011.

What is a hoagie in Scotland?

The hoagie wrap is

a treat native to Central Scotland

, seemingly flourishing in towns where the local Indian takeaway is the only food outlet and people just need something more from life. It’s got doner meat, sometimes chicken tikka, chips, cheese, and hoagie sauce, all wrapped up in a chapati.

Does PA say hoagie?

In Southeastern PA,

the hoagie is a way of life

. … Over time, that was shortened to a nickname, “hoggies,” which then, some think due to the Mid-Atlantic accent, transmuted into “hoagie” (which were sometimes written as “hoogie”).

What’s the difference between American and Italian hoagie?

American sub sandwich also known as a hoagie or American hero is a submarine sandwich that is

similar to the Italian sub

. While the Italian one used cured ham and cheese from Italy, the American version focuses on American cheeses and deli meats.

Sophia Kim
Author
Sophia Kim
Sophia Kim is a food writer with a passion for cooking and entertaining. She has worked in various restaurants and catering companies, and has written for several food publications. Sophia's expertise in cooking and entertaining will help you create memorable meals and events.