Skip to main content

What Happened To Matthew And Marilla Brother?

by
Last updated on 6 min read

Michael Cuthbert, the older brother of Matthew and Marilla, died in childhood, leaving them as the only surviving siblings.

How did Matthew and Marilla brother died?

Matthew Cuthbert died of a heart attack after learning that his and Marilla’s savings were lost in a bank failure.

Honestly, it’s pretty heartbreaking: near the very end of Anne of Green Gables, Matthew gets the news that their savings have disappeared in a bank crash. That shock hits him like a ton of bricks, triggering a fatal cardiac episode. Both Anne and Marilla are left reeling, grief‑stricken. In most cases, this kind of loss would send a family spiraling, and here it pushes Anne to sacrifice her scholarship so she can stay and help Marilla keep Green Gables afloat.

Source: Wikipedia.

Did Matthew and Marilla have a brother?

Yes, Matthew and Marilla had an older brother named Michael Cuthbert.

You know, Michael pops up in the backstory as the eldest of the three Cuthbert kids. After he died young, Matthew and Marilla had to step up and run the farm side by side. Honestly, that early loss really forged the tight, interdependent bond we see between them throughout the series.

What happened to Marilla and Matthews brother Michael?

Michael Cuthbert died in childhood, after which Matthew left school to help Marilla run Green Gables.

Honestly, the novels never spell out exactly how Michael died; they just tell us it happened while the siblings were still kids. Matthew’s choice to quit school and help Marilla run the farm makes sense when you think about the sudden need for extra hands after losing their oldest boy. That early burden, frankly, shaped his lifelong dedication to both the farm and his sister.

How did Michael Cuthbert die?

The exact cause of Michael Cuthbert’s death is not given in the books; he is only said to have died when he and Marilla were children.

We never get a clear answer from L.M. Montgomery about whether Michael fell ill, had an accident, or faced some other tragedy. That deliberate vagueness actually highlights the recurring theme of loss in the Cuthbert family story. Readers can only guess that his death came early enough to leave a mark on Matthew and Marilla’s younger years.

What illness does Marilla Cuthbert have?

Marilla Cuthbert experiences debilitating headaches and worsening vision as she ages.

You’ll notice these headaches and vision trouble cropping up in the later books, where Marilla starts worrying she might end up an invalid like her own mother. Most likely, the headaches come from stress and eye strain, and her weakening sight means Anne has to step in for reading and letters. Even so, her vision never goes out completely.

Source: Britannica.

Are Matthew and Marilla married?

No, Matthew and Marilla are not married; they are brother and sister who share a home at Green Gables.

Honestly, they’re just brother and sister sharing a roof, which was pretty normal for unmarried siblings on late‑19th‑century Prince Edward Island. Matthew’s shy nature and Marilla’s strict sense of propriety only strengthen that platonic vibe. All in all, their bond is shown as deep mutual reliance, not romance.

Who married Diana Barry?

Diana Barry married Fred Wright, a schoolmate from Avonlea.

Fred Wright shows up later as Diana’s husband and the dad of their kids. Their relationship is portrayed as a steady, loving partnership that really reflects the series’ emphasis on community and continuity. Because of this marriage, Diana can stay a loyal friend to Anne while also starting her own family.

Source: IMDb (Anne with an E).

Why didnt Marilla marry John?

Marilla turned down John Blythe’s proposal because he wanted to travel the world while she wished to stay at Green Gables.

John Blythe’s love of adventure just didn’t mesh with Marilla’s fierce attachment to Green Gables and her duty to Matthew. She preferred the steady rhythm of farm life to constant wandering, and that choice really highlights how steadfast and home‑focused she is.

Who is older Matthew or Marilla?

Matthew Cuthbert is the older sibling; Marilla was born after him.

According to the books, Matthew came into the world in the early 1820s, a few years ahead of Marilla, who was born around 1824. That age gap naturally puts him in the older‑brother, protector role for their whole lives. And honestly, the way Matthew stepped up after Michael’s death really set the tone for their sibling dynamic.

Does Marilla Cuthbert go blind?

Marilla’s eyesight worsens with age, but she does not go completely blind in the original books.

You’ll see her vision getting worse, making reading and fine work a real hassle, which is why Anne often steps in to help. That said, the books never say she goes completely blind; instead, they focus on her worry about becoming helpless. In most cases, this kind of decline is just a sign of aging, not a full‑blown disability.

Does Anne marry Gilbert?

Yes, Anne Shirley marries Gilbert Blythe after a long courtship.

Their wedding happens later in the series, once Anne finishes school and comes back to Avonlea. Together they raise seven kids and build a life that’s all about love, learning, and community. Honestly, this union feels like the perfect payoff for Anne’s romantic and aspirational journey.

Does Matthew commit suicide in Anne with an E?

In “Anne with an E,” Matthew attempts suicide but does not succeed, and later vows not to try again.

The TV show throws in a dramatic twist: Matthew, crushed by the money loss, thinks about ending his life to get the insurance payout. He doesn’t succeed, and Jeannie—an old flame—talks him out of it. Of course, this is pure invention; in the original novel Matthew’s death is just a tragic accident.

Who does Diana Barry end up with?

Diana Barry ends up married to Fred Wright, her longtime schoolmate from Avonlea.

After she ties the knot with Fred, Diana goes on to raise a family and stays Anne’s closest confidante all the way through the series. Their marriage is shown as a partnership rooted in shared history and mutual respect. Honestly, Diana’s lasting friendship with Anne really drives home the theme of lifelong kinship that runs through the books.

Does Matthew die in Anne of Green Gables?

Yes, Matthew Cuthbert dies of a heart attack upon hearing that his and Marilla’s money was lost in a bank failure.

The loss of their savings sets off that fatal heart attack right when Anne is getting ready to head off to university. Matthew’s death pushes her to give up her scholarship so she can stay and help Marilla. Honestly, this scene is one of the most heart‑wrenching in the book, hammering home the themes of love, duty, and sudden tragedy.

Was Anne of Green Gables mentally ill?

Anne Shirley is not depicted as mentally ill in the novels, though later readers have speculated about conditions like ADHD or bipolar disorder.

Anne’s bright imagination, strong emotions, and the occasional down‑to‑earth sadness are just part of her lively personality, not signs of a clinical condition. The novels actually celebrate her resilience, creativity, and joy‑filled spirit. That said, any attempt to slap a modern psychiatric label on her is purely interpretive—there’s nothing in the text to back it up.

Edited and fact-checked by the FixAnswer editorial team.
Emily Lee

Emily is a passionate arts and entertainment writer who covers everything from music and film to visual arts and cultural trends.