Contestability is the
idea that two separate sources can draw different conclusions about a historical person, concept or event
. Contestability most commonly occurs between two modern sources, typically academics, who have studied the surviving material in detail, but hold two different interpretations of the past.
What makes a source not useful?
Since a source's usefulness is based primarily upon its ability to provide valuable information on your topic, there are four different ways to prove that a source is useful: … It contradicts information from another source. You can best show this by
providing quotes from both sources
.
What is an example of contestability?
Contestability occurs when
particular interpretations about the past are open to debate
, for example, as a result of a lack of evidence or different perspectives, with debate often remaining intractable. Some students might question the value of a discipline that seems incapable of producing ‘the truth'.
What is a contestable question?
contestable –
capable of being contested
.
questionable – subject to question
; “questionable motives”; “a questionable reputation”; “a fire of questionable origin” incontestable, incontestible – incapable of being contested or disputed.
How do you know if a source is useful to a historian?
The measure of a source's usefulness is based upon the question being asked of it. If a
source provides any information about the specific topic you're investigating
, it is considered to be a useful source.
What makes a good source?
A reliable source is one that provides a thorough, well-reasoned theory, argument, discussion, etc.
based on strong evidence
. Scholarly, peer-reviewed articles or books -written by researchers for students and researchers. Original research, extensive bibliography.
Why is it important to use good sources?
It is important to use credible sources in an academic research paper
because your audience will expect you to have backed up your assertions with credible evidence
. … Using evidence that does not come from a credible source of information will not convince your reader that your claim is plausible or even correct.
What is an example of contestability in history?
Contestability occurs when particular interpretations about the past are open to debate, for example as
a result of a lack of evidence or different perspectives
, with debate often remaining intractable. Some students might question the value of a discipline that seems incapable of producing ‘the truth'.
How do you identify contestability?
- Two different sources provide contradictory explanations of the same thing (such as significance, motives or consequences)
- Two different sources use the same primary sources but draw different conclusions.
- A source mentions that there are alternate ways of understanding the topic.
What are the features of evidence in history?
In other words, evidence is just one aspect of a historical source. Other aspects include:
type of source, author, date, purpose, motive, perspective, language etc
.
What is a contestable period?
The contestability period is a clause in a life insurance policy according to which
if the policyholder expires within two years of purchasing the policy
, the insurance company can contest or question the claim raised by his/her beneficiaries.
What is contestable consumer?
Contestable Consumer. a consumer who is,
in accordance with the Electricity Act
, eligible to purchase electricity: (a) from a Retailer; (b) directly from any Wholesale Electricity Market; or.
What are contestable works?
Contestable works are
the elements of the connections work which can be undertaken by an ICP or IDNO rather than
WPD. Non-contestable works are the elements of the connections work which must be completed by WPD or our appointed agents.
What is the validity of a source?
The first is the validity of the information. This is the
truthfulness of the source in respect to the information presented
. The second piece of analyzing a source is to look at the reliability of the source. Reliability is, literally, the extent to which we can rely on the source of the data.
What makes a good history source?
They can be
firsthand testimony or evidence created
during the time period that you are studying. Primary sources may include diaries, letters, interviews, oral histories, photographs, newspaper articles, government documents, poems, novels, plays, and music.
What are the 3 historical sources?
Materials used to study history can be classified into three types:
primary, secondary and tertiary sources
.
