Which Christmas Carol Movie Is Closest To The Book?

by | Last updated on January 24, 2024

, , , ,
  1. 1 A Christmas Carol (1999)
  2. 2 A Christmas Carol (Short Film, 1971) …
  3. 3 Disney's A Christmas Carol (2009) …
  4. 4 A Christmas Carol (1985) …
  5. 5 BBC Version (1977) …
  6. 6 A Christmas Carol (1951) …
  7. 7 A Christmas Carol (1938) …

Is A Christmas Carol movie the same as the book?

A Christmas Carol 2009 version movie and the book have many differences and many similarities, but overall

it tells the same story the

way that Charles Dicken's originally told it.

Which movie version of Christmas Carol is best?

  1. 1 Best: Scrooge (A Christmas Carol) (1951) – 8.1.
  2. 2 Worst: Ms. …
  3. 3 Best: A Christmas Carol (1984) – 7.8. …
  4. 4 Worst: A Christmas Carol: The Musical (2004) – 6.5. …
  5. 5 Best: The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992) – 7.7. …
  6. 6 Worst: Scrooge (1935) – 6.6. …

How many different versions of A Christmas Carol are there?

So, how many are there total?

135

! The most famous ones that you'll see on TV this season are Mickey's Christmas Carol from 1983, the George C. Scott version (1984), Scrooge (1951), and Disney's A Christmas Carol — which stars Jim Carrey as not only Scrooge, but the three ghosts as well.

Which version of A Christmas Carol is the scariest?


A Christmas Carol (1984)

Scott's performance is the most substantial reason to watch this version, but for the horror fan, it's also one of the darkest and spookiest versions of the story. That includes Frank Finley's (Lifeforce) take on Marley.

What is the most faithful adaptation of A Christmas Carol?

The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992)

The best-acted, most powerfully portrayed Ebenezer Scrooge is Michael Caine's, and the most-faithful, most heart-wrenching Christmas Carol adaptation belongs to

the muppets

.

What is the most popular Christmas carol?

  • Silent Night.
  • God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen.
  • O Come All Ye Faithful.
  • O Holy Night.
  • What Child is This?
  • We Three Kings.
  • The First Noel.
  • Away in a Manger.

What is the oldest version of A Christmas Carol?


Scrooge (1935)

Now we're solidly into the classics. Again, your mileage may vary here, but for my money and time, these three are the best traditional adaptations of A Christmas Carol that currently exist. The oldest of them is this 1935 version starring Sir Seymour Hicks in the role of Scrooge.

Is A Christmas Carol based on a true story?

But is A Christmas Carol a true story? Well TBH,

it's not based on anything in particular

. However, the character of Ebenezer Scrooge and the dire straights of the poorest people living in the city of London at the time drew from real people and places. Scrooge is believed to be based on two different men.

Who was the best Ebenezer Scrooge?

  • Best stage Scrooge: Charles Dickens.
  • Best radio Scrooge: Lionel Barrymore.
  • Best film Scrooge: Alastair Sim.
  • Best Scrooge with puppets: Michael Caine.

Is Christmas Carol on Netflix?


A Christmas Carol is not available on Netflix

. But there are plenty of great noel-centric titles on Netflix like Angela's Christmas Wish and How the Grinch Stole Christmas. There are so many yuletide options on the streaming service, from cartoon Christmas stories all the way to romantic affairs.

Who is the best Scrooge actor?

  1. 1 Alastair Sim. Alastair Sim is the quintessential Scrooge.
  2. 2 George C. Scott. …
  3. 3 Seymour Hicks. …
  4. 4 Michael Caine. …
  5. 5 Patrick Stewart. …
  6. 6 Christopher Plummer. …
  7. 7 Jim Carrey. …
  8. 8 Tim Curry. …

Why is A Christmas Carol creepy?

A Christmas Carol is a true ghost story, and

its ghosts are genuinely creepy

. Yet it is also deeply invested in coziness, and familial warmth and love and generosity, to the point of self-parodying sentimentality. The rapid switch between these two aesthetic modes is what makes the book work.

Why is Scrooge scared of Marley?

Its livid color creates a sense of horror in Scrooge, but he is

not so easily terrified

. … However, Scrooge trembles when Marley's ghost tells him that his chain was forged by himself; further, Marley's ghost informs Scrooge of the “ponderous chain” Scrooge has forged himself.

Is Jacob Marley in purgatory?

After his death,

he is held in purgatory

and will only be released if he can aid in the redemption of his business partner, Ebenezer Scrooge.

How old is Ebenezer Scrooge in A Christmas Carol?

Personal Data: Ebenezer Scrooge is an

approximately 50-year-old Caucasian male

. He is single and has never been married.

Maria Kunar
Author
Maria Kunar
Maria is a cultural enthusiast and expert on holiday traditions. With a focus on the cultural significance of celebrations, Maria has written several blogs on the history of holidays and has been featured in various cultural publications. Maria's knowledge of traditions will help you appreciate the meaning behind celebrations.