Why do the prisoners believe that the shadows are real? Are they wrong? They believed the shadows were real
because they would represent perceptions that make people believe they have truthful knowledge
. How do the other prisoners react to what the escaped prisoner tells them about the outside world?
What do the prisoners perceive the shadows to be why?
The sounds of the people walking echo off the shadowed wall, the prisoners falsely perceive these sounds to be that of the shadows. Socrates suggests that, for the prisoners, the shadows of
artifacts would constitute reality
, because they have not seen the light.
Why can the prisoners only see shadows?
When a person lives with an illusion their whole life, it comes to a
point that it becomes their reality
, as the prisoners in the cave they had being chained since childhood so their reality are their own shadow. That happens in life as well, we become so stuck into our illusion that we believe it is true.
Why does the prisoner need time to adjust to each new freedom as he emerges from the cave?
Why will the prisoner need to adjust to the world outside the cave? This new world will appear contrary to what he had thought had been real for a long time so
all realities will appear unfamiliar and foreign to him because he was misconceived
. Plus he has to deal with the sun.
What will happen to the prisoner who leaves the cave after they come to understand what they see?
He would experience pain and continue to believe that the shadows of the objects are truer than the objects. What would happen when the prisoner leaves the cave?
He would grow used to the light of reality in stages.
What do shadows represent?
Shadows represent
secrets, deceit, uncertainty, and dark magic
. They are usually associated with darkness and therefore given negative traits. Overall, shadows symbolize: Secrets.
Why does Plato ask how the prisoner would feel if he were to be put back in the cave?
Why? He wouldn’t like to get back to that misery,
he wouldn’t be able to put
a step in that cave, after he has seen his reality in the outside world who would of life to step back in the darkness.
What are the stages of the liberated prisoners experience?
What are the stages of the liberated prisoner’s experience outside the cave?
The prisoners are first blinded, then they can see the shadows, then they are unshackled and see the fire, which is basic knowledge, then they can see the sunlight which is reason and they can see a tree which is a form
.
What do the shadows on the wall represent in Plato’s more general theory of knowledge and reality?
The shadows on the wall represent
an illusion of reality that the people viewing the wall try to interpret without understanding the truth
; that the shadows are only shadows. The viewers of the wall have never genuinely seen what the objects which cause those shadows look like.
What are the only things the prisoners can see?
The prisoners cannot see any of what is happening behind them, they are
only able to see the shadows cast upon the cave wall in front of them
. The sounds of the people talking echo off the walls, and the prisoners believe these sounds come from the shadows (514c).
Why do the prisoners reject the escaped prisoner?
But the prisoners think that he is dangerous because the information that he tells them is so abstract and opposed to what they know. The prisoners choose not to be free because they
are comfortable in their own world of ignorance
, and they are hostile to people who want to give them an alternative view of the world.
What is the message of allegory of the cave?
The main theme of Plato’s Allegory of the Cave in the Republic is that
human perception cannot derive true knowledge, and instead
, real knowledge can only come via philosophical reasoning. In Plato’s example, prisoners live their entire lives in a cave, only able to see shadows.
Why does the escaped prisoner return to the cave?
Escaped prisoner returns to cave
to inform others of his findings
. They do not believe him and threaten to kill him if he tries to free them. Cave represents people who believe that knowledge comes from what we see and hear in the world- empirical evidence. … Sun represents philosophical truth and knowledge.
When the prisoner leaves the cave everything will immediately become clear to them?
14. The prisoners in the cave, Plato explains, are only acquainted with shadows and echoes. 15. When people leave the cave, everything will immediately become clear to them.
What are the four stages of the allegory of the cave?
- Imprisonment in the cave (the imaginary world)
- Release from chains (the real, sensual world)
- Ascent out of the cave (the world of ideas)
- The way back to help our fellows.
What are the four stages of the Allegory of the Cave quizlet?
-The first stage is imagination. The second stage is belief. Cognitive stage of thought.
Stage of understanding
.
