Granger compares mankind to the phoenix, a mythological creature that is consumed by fire only to rise from its own ashes in a cycle that it repeats eternally. He suggests that man’s advantage over the phoenix is
his ability to recognize when he has made a mistake
, so that eventually he will learn not to repeat it.
Why does Granger compare humans to the phoenix?
For Granger, society is like the
phoenix because it, too, never learns from it mistakes
. Quite literally, his society allows itself to be engulfed in flames—the flames of the firemen—as it seeks to destroy books and book-reading. Just like the phoenix, it does not realize that these flames are the problem.
What does Granger’s reference to the phoenix symbolize?
The phoenix is a symbol for
renewal, for life that follows death in a cleansing fire
. After the city is reduced to ashes by bombers in Fahrenheit 451, Granger makes a direct comparison between human beings and the story of the phoenix. Both destroy themselves in fire.
When Granger compares society to a phoenix What is the only way he says that society can ever change?
Granger compares society to the Phoenix. Why does he make this comparison?
The Phoenix is a mythical creature who burns up, then is reborn from the ashes
; he hopes that after the war, society will also be able to be reborn.
Do you think Grangers comparison of humanity to the phoenix adds to a major theme of the novel?
Granger’s comparison is accurate and adds to the significant theme of the novel, which is that
books are important to remind humanity of our past mistakes
. … Similar to how the Phoenix continually destroys itself, humanity is also destructive.
How is humanity like a phoenix?
Like the phoenix,
humans cyclically destroy themselves and their societies only to build up society again
. However, according to Granger, humans have the ability to remember and record what has happened in an attempt to avoid repeating past mistakes.
Why is Granger’s statement Montag ironic?
Why is Granger’s statement to Montag (“Welcome back from the dead.”) ironic? It is
ironic because they just saw someone innocent be killed in place for Montag
. How do Granger and the others preserve books? Granger and the others preserve the books by remembering them with their photographic memory.
Why do you think Granger says the Phoenix must be the first cousin to Man how are both similar How are they different?
Granger looks into the fire and realizes its life-giving quality as he utters the word “phoenix.” The phoenix, he says, was “a silly damn bird” that “every few hundred years” built a pyre “and burned himself up.” Granger imagines the bird as “first cousin to Man”
because the bird continually went through rebirth only
…
What is Grangers promise at the end of the novel?
The promise at the end of the novel is that
a new time is about to begin and that humanity is not completely doomed
.
Why did Granger want Montag to lead them back to the city how does Granger view Montag?
Why did Granger want Montag to lead them back to the city? …
Montag was encouraged and young, and ready to be the new leader of a new beginning.
What is the purpose of Granger’s speech about his grandfather?
Why did Granger tell Montag the story of his grandfather?
He wanted to explain the importance of changing the world
.
What is Granger’s plan for changing society?
Granger’s overall plan for society is
to build great and powerful inventions and teach the people of the cities things that these men never were allowed to learn as they were growing up
.
What is Granger’s attitude towards mankind?
He believes
that by having access to books, the people who remain after the blast can rebuild society along better lines
. He also believes that if people remember the experiences of who people who came before them and are reflective about the mistakes of the past, the society has a chance to improve itself.
In what way is humankind like the Phoenix in what way is humankind different?
The only difference is that
humans knowingly destroy themselves in a similar cycle
, which makes it all more frustrating; the phoenix dies and rises again because that is its nature and humans do the same even though they are aware of destroying themselves, but they can change and fix themselves.
What does Granger think their job is?
What does Granger think their job is? Granger says
that all the people in the woods are just receptacles for the knowledge in the books
. How does Montag feel about Mildred still being in the city? … It is interesting that Montag still has some feelings for Mildred.
Why are Granger and his group referred to as pieces of literature instead of by their names? What is this literary device called, and how does it function here? They are referred to as books
because they contain knowledge of the books they burned and have the memory of the book by photographic memory
.
What does Granger say is the wonderful thing about man?
“The wonderful thing about man,” says Granger,
“[is that] he never gets so discouraged […] that he gives up. […] He knows very well it is important and worth the doing.”
Granger’s words stay with Montag (and with the reader) even after the city is bombed to the ground.
What is the difference between the legacy of Granger’s grandfather to the memory of Mildred?
What is the difference between the legacy of Granger’s grandfather to the memory of Mildred?
Grangers grandfather actually did helpful and memorable things, unlike Mildred
. What image flashes before Montag’s eyes as the bomb is dropped on the city? He remembers everyone in his life.
Can a Phoenix turn into a human?
They can heal/regenerate from any and all non-fatal injuries. Pyroportation – Phoenixes can disappear and reappear at will in bursts of flames and take whoever is holding them along.
Shapeshifting – Phoenixes can take a human form to conceal their true form
, which is that of a giant bird.
Granger is a man who Montag meets once he has fled from the city. He is an academic who wrote a book about the individual and society (highly relevant in light of the deeper themes of Fahrenheit 451). He
serves as a guide to Montag, helping him transition in their new community with kindness and advice
.
Who was Granger in Fahrenheit 451?
Granger.
The leader of the “Book People
,” the group of hobo intellectuals Montag finds in the country. Granger is intelligent, patient, and confident in the strength of the human spirit. He is committed to preserving literature through the current Dark Age.
What does the Hearth and the Salamander symbolize in Fahrenheit 451?
Analysis. “The Hearth and the Salamander” focuses on
Montag’s job as a fireman and his home life
. The hearth, or fireplace, is a traditional symbol of the home, and the salamander is one of the official symbols of the firemen, as well as what they call their fire trucks.
Why does Granger call himself Plato’s Republic What are the men by the river doing?
Granger says that he himself is Plato’s Republic and another man at the campfire is Marcus Aurelius’s work. He introduces the
men by the authors they have memorized
. Granger explains that they all memorized books and then burned them, because keeping the books was too dangerous.
What is the significance of the title The Hearth and the Salamander?
“The Hearth and the Salamander”
Both of these symbols have to do with fire, the dominant image of Montag’s life—the
hearth because it contains the fire that heats a home
, and the salamander because of ancient beliefs that it lives in fire and is unaffected by flames.
What did Granger’s grandfather do?
Granger tells him a story about the death of his grandfather, stressing that his grandfather,
a sculptor
, was a man who “ did things to the world.” Granger believes that when people change even a small part of the world thoughtfully and deliberately, they leave behind enough of their souls to enable other people to …
How does f451 end?
The novel ends with
Montag escaping the city in the midst of a new declaration of war
. Once he’s deep in the country, Montag meets a band of roving intellectuals who have elected to preserve significant works of literature in their memory.
What is Granger’s hope for the future?
In Ray Bradbury’s novel, Fahrenheit 451, Granger is the leader of a group of intellectuals and a friend to Montag. His group memorizes
books to share with each other and to pass down to future generations in hopes that they will one day be able to rewrite the books to share with the world
.
What is one thing that Granger wants to do in the new city why?
Granger suggests that
building a mirror factory
is the first thing that they do to rebuild a society because that was the biggest problem in Montag’s society. … By creating mirrors a society can decide for themselves who they are and what they want to become.
What does Granger’s reference to the Phoenix symbolize?
The phoenix is a symbol for
renewal, for life that follows death in a cleansing fire
. After the city is reduced to ashes by bombers in Fahrenheit 451, Granger makes a direct comparison between human beings and the story of the phoenix. Both destroy themselves in fire.
Why are books banned in Fahrenheit 451?
In Fahrenheit 451, books were
forbidden as a means for the government to control the thoughts of the public
. Excuses such as offensive language and resentment over different levels of intellect, which reportedly made people feel bad, are some of the given reasons as to why books were banned.
What is implied when Granger allowed Montag to lead the people out of the city?
What is implied when Granger allows Montag to lead the people out of the city?
It shows that Montag has the best sense of direction
. It implies that Granger is self-conscious of their mission. It shows that Granger want Montag to feel in control of his destiny for the first time.
What does Montag learn from Granger?
At the end of part 3, of Ray Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451, Granger teaches Montag
the importance and purpose of purpose life
. Though there are many important lessons to be learned, Granger focuses on special ones for Montag.
When Granger compares society to a Phoenix What is the only way he says that society can ever change?
Granger compares society to the Phoenix. Why does he make this comparison?
The Phoenix is a mythical creature who burns up, then is reborn from the ashes
; he hopes that after the war, society will also be able to be reborn.
Why is Granger’s statement Montag ironic?
Why is Granger’s statement to Montag (“Welcome back from the dead.”) ironic? It is
ironic because they just saw someone innocent be killed in place for Montag
. How do Granger and the others preserve books? Granger and the others preserve the books by remembering them with their photographic memory.
Why did Granger cry at his grandfather’s funeral?
I cried
because he would never do them again
…” (Bradbury, 73). According to Granger, we miss the special actions of our loved ones and the unique way they impacted the world. He says he misses the way his grandfather carved a piece of wood, raised doves, told jokes, or played the violin.
Why does Granger tell Montag about his grandfather what point is Granger trying to make about Millie?
Why dose Granger tell Montag about his grandfather? What point is Granger trying to make about Millie? Granger tells Montag
his grandfather left a very good impression on him, while Millie has not left and impression on anyone
.
What does Granger compare their situation to now?
Expert Answers
Granger compares his society to
the phoenix
, a “silly damn bird” which is consumed by fire but then rises up from the ashes. The important point to note here is that the phoenix does this time after time.
How Will Granger’s group try to preserve civilization?
Granger’s group plans on preserving civilization by
memorizing books
. Through oral tradition, they hope to keep major works alive, pass the information onto their children, or until society is willing to hear this knowledge again.
What was Granger’s philosophy of life?
Granger’s philosophy of life is: “
Stuff you eyes with wonder, live as if you dropped dead in ten seconds. See the world. It’s more fantastic than any dream made of paid in factories
.
How is humanity like a phoenix?
Like the phoenix,
humans cyclically destroy themselves and their societies only to build up society again
. However, according to Granger, humans have the ability to remember and record what has happened in an attempt to avoid repeating past mistakes.
Why do you think Granger says the Phoenix must be the first cousin to Man how are both similar How are they different?
Granger looks into the fire and realizes its life-giving quality as he utters the word “phoenix.” The phoenix, he says, was “a silly damn bird” that “every few hundred years” built a pyre “and burned himself up.” Granger imagines the bird as “first cousin to Man”
because the bird continually went through rebirth only
…
What message does the life of the Phoenix gives us?
First, it represents
the cycle of death, rebirth, and renewed life
. It also stands for another concept: immortality. This made it an attractive symbol for Rome, sometimes called the Eternal City.
