What happens to make the “knife theory” invalid? Juror 8 revealed that
he had the same “one of a kind knife” that the defendant bought the night of the murder
(which also ended up being the murder weapon or like the murder weapon).
How did Juror 8 prove doubt about the knife?
Just when it looks as though the knife in question will get the defendant convicted, Juror #8
pulls the exact same type of knife out of his pocket and jams it into the table in the middle of the room
.
Why do they want to see the switchblade knife does Juror 8 prove?
When Eight sticks a matching knife in the wall,
the murder weapon represents the certainty of the jurors that is quickly draining away
. Initially, eleven out of twelve jurors felt convinced of the accused’s guilt.
Why does Juror #8 say he voted not guilty?
In the first vote, Juror 8 is the only one to vote not guilty. … He does this not because he really feels that the defendant is necessarily innocent, but for another reason altogether. He votes not guilty because he
feels that the group should discuss a case with such serious consequences before deciding
.
What does Juror 8 prove?
The 8
th
juror states that
he cannot send a boy to die without “talking about it first”
. … According to the 8
th
juror, the man had a stroke so it would have taken a minimum of 42 seconds to get to the door. This proves that he simply “assumed it was the boy” (36). Evidently, he believes that the old man sought attention.
What was Juror #3 doing that made Juror #8 angry causing him to exclaim This isn’t a game?
What was Juror#3 doing that made Juror#8 angry, causing him to exclaim, “this isn’t a game!”?
He was playing tic-tac-toe.
What are the rebuttals Juror 8 gives to each piece of evidence?
Juror #8 picks apart each piece of
evidence to persuade the others
. Here are some of the observations: The old man could have invented his story because he craved attention. … Some members of the jury decide that during a stressful situation, anyone could forget the names of the movie they had seen.
What does Juror #8 say that makes Juror #3 so angry?
What does Juror #8 say that makes Juror #3 so angry?
Accuses him of being the murderer. Tells him he thinks that the defendant is guilty. Accuses him of voting guilty just
because he wants to see the defendant die, not because he truly believes he’s guilty.
What does Juror 8 do that shocks everyone?
What proposition does EIGHT make his fellow jurors? They
will have a secret ballot vote
, he won’t vote, and if everybody votes “guilty” he will change his vote.
What did juror No 8 prove about the kid not being able to remember the name of the movie?
“He claimed that he was at the movies at the time of the killing and yet one hour later he couldn’t remember
the names of the films he saw or who played in them
.” Juror #8 suggested that it wasn’t surprising that the defendant couldn’t remember the details of the films – he was questioned about them by the police while …
Why is Juror 3 angry?
Examples of possible responses: In 12 Angry Men, Juror 3 is
the most challenging juror because of his unwillingness to work well with the other jurors
. Juror 3 tries to bully the other jurors into voting guilty.
Why did Juror 9 change his vote not guilty?
Why had Nine changed his vote? Who is Nine? Nine changed his vote
because Juror number 8 had courage to stand against everyone else
, and he 8 gambled for support and made 9 want to hear more.
What does each juror tell the 8th juror to convince him that the defendant is guilty?
Juror 8 declares that
they must not let prejudice cloud the facts
. He asks the three “guilty” voters why they are still convinced.
Is Juror 8 based on true story?
The
film is based on a true story
, in which ordinary people on South Korea’s historic inaugural citizen’s jury became passionately involved in uncovering the truth about a matricide case. … The film clocked up more than 2 million admissions and $16m on local release, according to the Korean Film Council (KOFIC).
Is Juror 8 making an effective case?
By the end of the movie, Juror #8 has
proven himself to be a true hero for standing
by his principles and having the courage and skill to put them to work. He eventually gets the jury to find the defendant Not Guilty, and in the process, he avoids sending an innocent 18 year-old kid to jail.
How did Juror Number 8 convince the other jurors?
Finally, Juror #8 helps convince
some of the last holdouts by showing them that the other key witness was almost certainly not wearing her glasses when she allegedly saw the boy kill his father
. For most of the jurors, this is the final nail in the coffin, and the verdict eventually turns to Not Guilty.
