Sylvia doesn’t tell the stranger where to find the heron’s nest
because she knows he’ll kill the herons
, and she doesn’t want that to happen. … Even though the hunter could improve Sylvia and her grandmother’s lives, she can’t make herself a party to the death of the heron by helping him find the nest.
Do you believe Sylvia made the right choice when she protected the white heron explain your answer?
Ultimately, Sylvia makes
the right choice based on her beliefs
—to do otherwise would have been hypocritical. Although Sylvia chooses to protect the heron, the story seems to indicate that Mrs. Tilley would have made a different decision if it were up to her.
Does Sylvia make the right decision in not telling the young man where the white heron nests Why or why not?
She does not tell the young man where
the heron is in order to save the heron
. Her conflict is found in trying to please the world (the man and her grandmother), or to save the bird. She chooses to protect the heron.
What does Sylvia have to gain by revealing the white herons location?
The hunter, in an attempt to persuade Sylvia to reveal the location of the white heron’s nest, says that
he would give ten dollars to any person who could help him find it
.
Why does Sylvia consider helping the young man?
Why does Sylvia consider helping the young man? She is charmed by his attention and wants to please him.
She enjoys helping people
. It is part of her religion.
What does Sylvia do at the end of a white heron?
Although she’s torn, Sylvia decides
to find the heron for the hunter
. She climbs the highest tree in the area, has a magical experience, and sees the heron.
What does the white heron represent?
The white heron symbolizes
the independence and wonder of nature
, which must be preserved against the destructive forces of industrialization and greed. When Sylvia sees the heron’s spectacular perspective on the world from the top of the tree, she makes a moral choice to refuse to help the hunter kill the bird.
Why does Sylvia not speak in the White Heron?
Sylvia remains silent
and doesn’t speak because she doesn’t want to betray the loyalty of the white heron. When the handsome hunter, who manages to charm Sylvia, asks her where the beautiful bird might be hiding, Sylvia decides to remain silent and not give away its location.
How Old Is Sylvia in a white heron?
“A White Heron” is the story of Sylvia, a
nine-year-old girl
, who goes in quest of an exotic, almost miraculous bird. She herselfhas unusual gifts.
What makes Sylvia’s decision so difficult?
She wants to please him with her knowledge
, but she “cannot tell the heron’s secret and give its life away.” She feels pulled, evidently, between her desire to make the hunter happy and her need to protect the beautiful bird with whom she watched the sunrise. This is what makes her decision so difficult.
What is the main reason Sylvia climbs the tree?
Climbing the great pine allows Sylvia to spot the white heron from high above the forest. She climbs the tree
to find the heron’s nest so that she can tell the hunter
, thus pleasing him and earning the money her grandmother needs.
Why does Sylvia watch the hop toad?
In Sarah Orne Jewett’s “A White Heron
How does Sylvia feel about living on her grandmother’s farm?
How does Sylvia feel about living on her grandmother’s farm?
She likes it very much. She thinks it is a beautiful place to live. She didn’t like it at all
.
Why does the Hunter want the white heron?
The hunter represents
the industrialization that threatens to conquer and destroy nature
in order to satisfy human greed, and Sylvia must reject him in order to truly value her natural environment.
How did Sylvia find a white heron s nest?
This young man is searching in particular for the rare white heron, and he is sure that it makes its nest in the vicinity. …
She decides to climb the tallest tree in the forest so that she can see the entire countryside
, and she finds the heron, just as she had thought she would.
Which word best describes Sylvia in a white heron?
At first, Sylvia is described as
“a little girl”
and “small and silly Sylvia”. As she begins her journey up the tree, she is described as a “spark of human spirit”. Finally, as she reaches the top of the tree, she is called “a pale star” and stands “triumphant”.
