Why Should The Government Not Regulate Sugar?

by | Last updated on January 24, 2024

, , , ,

Government Should Not Regulate Sugar Like Alcohol Or Tobacco

to Curb Obesity

. … The science behind the proposed restrictions on sugar is sound. The substance can indeed kill you if consumed in great enough amounts, and it may even be addictive.

Does the government regulate sugar?

“Obesity is not the cause; rather, it is a marker.” That's why it's time that

the government steps in and regulates sugar in ways similar to tobacco and alcohol

, the authors wrote. That includes taxes, age restrictions and other policies to control the distribution of sugar.

Should sugar be regulated like alcohol and tobacco?

Writing in the journal Nature, UCSF pediatrician Robert Lustig and colleagues suggest

regulating sugar just like alcohol and tobacco

—with taxes and age limits, for example—due to what they call the “toxic” effects of too much sweet stuff.

Why is sugar regulated?

Blood sugar levels are

regulated by negative feedback in order to keep the body in balance

. The levels of glucose in the blood are monitored by many tissues, but the cells in the pancreatic islets are among the most well understood and important.

Is alcohol the same as sugar?

One reason why many experts, like Lustig, thinks we should regulate sugar like alcohol lies in the fact that the metabolic effect of sugar, especially fructose sugar,

is nearly identical to that of ethanol from drinking alcohol

.

What are three ways the government might regulate sugar?

Among their suggestions:

impose a sugar tax, limit sales during school hours

, don't allow children to buy sugary drinks, remove soft drinks from the food stamp program, and cut fructose from the FDA's Generally Regarded as Safe list of ingredients that can be added in unlimited amounts to foods.

When did sugar tax start?

Manufacturers of soft drinks containing more than 5g of sugar per 100ml have been made to pay a levy of 18p a litre to the Treasury, or 24p a litre for sugar content over 8g per 100ml, since the tax came into force in

April 2018

.

What are the ingredients for sugar?

Sugar/sucrose

Often called “table sugar,” it's a naturally occurring carbohydrate found in many fruits and plants. Table sugar is usually extracted from sugar cane or sugar beets. It consists of

50% glucose and 50% fructose, bound together

. Sucrose is found in many foods.

What organ controls your blood sugar?


The liver

produces, stores and releases glucose depending on the body's need for glucose, a monosaccharide. This is primarily indicated by the hormones insulin – the main regulator of sugar in the blood – and glucagon.

What happens if it is unable to regulate blood sugar?

Hyperglycemia can

damage the vessels that supply blood to vital organs

, which can increase the risk of heart disease and stroke, kidney disease, vision problems, and nerve problems. These problems don't usually show up in kids or teens who have had the disease for only a few years.

What hormone decreases blood sugar?


Glucagon

works along with the hormone insulin to control blood sugar levels and keep them within set levels. Glucagon is released to stop blood sugar levels dropping too low (hypoglycaemia), while insulin is released to stop blood sugar levels rising too high (hyperglycaemia).

What is worse alcohol or sugar?

We noticed that there's a bit of controversy over which is worse.

Sugar can be like

a drug and create an addiction that can lead to major health problems. The same can be said for alcohol – it's a toxin and is difficult for the liver to metabolise. Both can significantly contribute to weight gain.

Does alcohol turn into sugar in your body?

While

moderate amounts of alcohol may cause blood sugar to rise

, excess alcohol can actually decrease your blood sugar level — sometimes causing it to drop into dangerous levels, especially for people with type 1 diabetes. Beer and sweet wine contain carbohydrates and may raise blood sugar.

What is the relationship between alcohol and sugar?

Alcohol consumption

causes an increase in insulin secretion

, which leads to low blood sugar (otherwise known as hypoglycaemia). This causes light headedness and fatigue, and is also responsible for a host of longer-term alcohol-related health problems.

How Insulin lowers the blood glucose level?

When you take

insulin

, it helps to move glucose out of your bloodstream and into cells. Your cells use some of that sugar for energy and then store any leftover sugar in your fat, muscles, and liver for later. Once the sugar moves into your cells, your blood glucose level should go back to normal.

Why the sugar tax is bad?

It seems straightforward: Taxing makes them more expensive, reducing consumption and leading would-be soda-guzzlers to lead healthier lives. Obesity declines, as do the myriad health conditions associated with a sugar-rich diet.

Sophia Kim
Author
Sophia Kim
Sophia Kim is a food writer with a passion for cooking and entertaining. She has worked in various restaurants and catering companies, and has written for several food publications. Sophia's expertise in cooking and entertaining will help you create memorable meals and events.