Internal and external validity are concepts that reflect whether or not the results of a study are trustworthy and meaningful. While internal validity relates to how well a study is conducted (its structure),
external validity relates to how applicable the findings are to the real world
.
Can you have external validity without internal validity?
Lack of internal validity implies that the results of the study deviate from the truth, and, therefore, we cannot draw any conclusions; hence, if the results of a trial are not internally valid,
external validity is irrelevant
.
What affects external validity?
There are seven threats to external validity:
selection bias, history, experimenter effect, Hawthorne effect, testing effect, aptitude-treatment and situation effect
.
Does increasing internal validity decrease external validity?
A lab setting ensures higher internal validity
because external influences can be minimized. However, the external validity diminishes because a lab environment is different than the ‘outside world’ (that does have external influencing factors).
What increases external validity?
Some researchers believe that a good way to increase external validity is by
conducting field experiments
. In a field experiment, people’s behavior is studied outside the laboratory, in its natural setting. … Through replication, researchers can study a given research question with maximal internal and external validity.
Is internal validity more important than external validity?
An experimental design is expected to have both internal and external validity.
Internal validity is the most important requirement
, which must be present in an experiment before any inferences about treatment effects are drawn. To establish internal validity, extraneous validity should be controlled.
What is the difference between Construct validity internal validity and external validity?
Differences. The essential difference between internal and external validity is that internal validity refers
to the structure of a study and its variables
while external validity relates to how universal the results are.
Why is external validity important?
External validity helps to answer the question: can the research be applied to the “real world”?
If your research is applicable to other experiments, settings, people, and times
, then external validity is high. If the research cannot be replicated in other situations, external validity is low.
What is the difference between external validity and generalizability?
External validity is a function of the researcher and the design of the research. Generalizability is
a function of both the researcher and the user
.
How do you determine internal validity?
- Your treatment and response variables change together.
- Your treatment precedes changes in your response variables.
- No confounding or extraneous factors can explain the results of your study.
What can affect internal validity?
- Subject variability.
- Size of subject population.
- Time given for the data collection or experimental treatment.
- History.
- Attrition.
- Maturation.
- Instrument/task sensitivity.
How do you determine external validity?
Results External validity refers to the question whether results are generalizable to persons other than the population in the original study. The only formal way to establish the external validity would be
to repeat the study for that specific target population
.
What are the 12 threats to internal validity?
Threats to internal validity include
history, maturation, attrition, testing, instrumentation, statistical regression, selection bias and diffusion of treatment
.
What improves internal validity?
Controls are required to assure internal validity (causality) of research designs, and can be accomplished in four ways: (1) manipulation, (2)
elimination
, (3) inclusion, and (4) statistical control, and (5) randomization.
Does sample size affect external validity?
Very small samples undermine
the internal and external validity of a study. Very large samples tend to transform small differences into statistically significant differences – even when they are clinically insignificant.
What is external validity in psychology?
External validity is
another name for the generalizability of results
, asking “whether a causal relationship holds over variation in persons, settings, treatments and outcomes.”
1
A classic example of an external validity concern is whether traditional economics or psychology lab experiments carried out on college …
