A within-subjects design is
more statistically powerful than a between-subjects design
, because individual variation is removed. To achieve the same level of power, a between-subjects design often requires double the number of participants (or more) that a within-subjects design does.
What are the advantages of within-subjects design?
Perhaps the most important advantage of within-subject designs is that they
make it less likely that a real difference that exists between your conditions will stay undetected or be covered by random noise
. Individual participants bring in to the test their own history, background knowledge, and context.
Which of the following is an advantage of a within-subjects experimental design?
An advantage of using a within-subjects design is
that fewer participants are required overall (economizing) because the same participants are observed in each group
. A second advantage of using the within-subjects design is that the test statistic for this design has greater power to detect an effect between groups.
Which of the following is an advantage of the within-subjects design compared to the between-subjects design?
Within-subjects designs cope with the problem of error variance by: using the same subjects in all treatment conditions. An advantage of a within-subjects design over a matched-pairs between-subjects design is that:
measuring subject characteristics is unnecessary in a within-subjects design.
What is the main advantage of conducting an experiment using a within-subjects design rather than a between-subjects design?
What is the main advantage of conducting an experiment using a within-subjects design rather than a between-subjects design? A within
-subjects design controls more extraneous variables.
What is the main disadvantage of a within-subjects design?
According to the text, a disadvantage of a within-subjects design is that:
each subject must spend more time in your experiment and thus may become fatigued
. A serious problem with the within-subjects design is that: there is a potential for carryover effects.
What are the disadvantages of within-subjects design?
Fatigue
is another potential drawback of using a within-subject design. Participants may become exhausted, bored, or simply uninterested after taking part in multiple treatments or tests. Finally, performance on subsequent tests can also be affected by practice effects.
What does between-subjects mean?
Between-subjects is
a type of experimental design in which the subjects of an experiment are assigned to different conditions
, with each subject experiencing only one of the experimental conditions. This is a common design used in psychology and other social science fields.
When should you use a within-subjects design?
It is used
when a particular individual difference variable or variables are considered especially likely to influence the outcome
, and a between-subjects design is desired. There are two groups, and each partcipant in one group is matched with a participant in the other group with respect to the variable of interest.
What is an example of within subject design?
Another common example of a within-subjects design is
medical testing
, where researchers try to establish whether a drug is effective or whether a placebo effect is in order. The researchers, in the crudest form of the test, will give all of the participants the placebo, for a time, and monitor the results.
What is a between subjects factorial design?
In a between-subjects factorial design,
all of the independent variables are manipulated between subjects
. For example, all participants could be tested either while using a cell phone or while not using a cell phone and either during the day or during the night. … This is called a mixed factorial design.
When should a within-subjects design not be used?
If the researcher is interested in treatment effects under minimum practice, the within-subjects design is inappropriate because
subjects are providing data for two of the three treatments (more generally, k – 1 of k treatments) under more than minimum practice
. A be- tween-subjects design would be obligatory.
What is the carry over effect?
Carryover effects are challenging for within-subjects research designs, that is,
when the same participants are exposed to all experimental treatments and results are compared across different treatments
. … This is known as a carryover effect.
Can you have a within and between-subjects design?
Yes
. Between-subjects and within-subjects designs can be combined in a single study when you have two or more independent variables (a factorial design). … If you test two variables, each level of one independent variable is combined with each level of the other independent variable to create different conditions.
What is a true experiment?
A true experiment is defined as
an experiment conducted where an effort is made to impose control over all other variables except the one under study
. … Dependent variable – the variable that is measured in a study. The experimenter does not control this variable.
What is the big disadvantage of using between?
Disadvantages. The main disadvantage with between-group designs is
that they can be complex and often require a large number of participants to generate any useful and reliable data
.
