Montresor’s revenge scheme is unsuccessful because it does not ultimately fulfill either of his two rules of revenge:
“I must not only punish, but punish with impunity”
and “the avenger [must] make himself felt as such to him who has done the wrong” (Poe 848).
Why is revenge not successful to Montresor?
First, revenge isn’t successful
if the person seeking revenge allows it to control him
. Montresor must not allow his desire for revenge to consume him. … This is why he says he must “punish with impunity.” He will make Fortunato pay for his insults, but Montresor will be free from any harm to himself.
What does Montresor consider a successful revenge?
Montresor is saying that a crime is only considered perfect when the criminal harms the victim and is able to avoid being punished for the crime they committed. … For Montresor, the perfect crime — or, more specifically, the perfect revenge
— requires that the avenger not get caught
.
What has Montresor not done to prepare for revenge?
What did Montresor not do to prepare for revenge? When Fortunato says: “
the cough is a mere nothing; it will not kill me, I shall not die of a cough
.” … The Montresor family crest is a golden human foot stepping on a snake that is bitting the heel.
Why is Montresor not satisfied with his revenge on Fortunato?
Montresor is satisfied with his revenge on Fortunato
because he doesn’t feel melancholy
. … Montresor is not justified in killing Fortunato because we don’t know for sure what Fortunato did to him.
What is Fortunato’s weakness?
In “The Cask of Amontillado,” Fortunato’s weakness is
his pride in his connoisseurship of wine
. It is this weakness that Montresor exploits in order to lure Fortunato to his death.
How does Montresor get revenge on Fortunato?
Montresor sought revenge on Fortunato because he had hurt Montresor for years, and now he has insulted him, and it has come to the final straw. … He states he has a famous bottle of Amontillado, and wants him to look at it, so he gets
Fortunato drunk enough to go down into the catacombs where Montresor can kill him
.
What does Montresor say about revenge?
In the first paragraph of the tale Montresor talks about his his general thougts on Revenge:
I must not only punish but punish with impunity
. A wrong is unredressed when retribution overtakes its redresser. It is equally unredressed when the avenger fails to make himself as such to him who has done the wrong.
Does Montresor succeed?
While Montresor
does succeed in luring Fortunato
into the catacombs and killing him, Montresor does not fully fulfill his requirements as to how he wanted to get his revenge. Montresor however does not fully succeed with the second condition that he set for himself.
Does Montresor follow his own rules of revenge?
Montresor’s revenge scheme
is unsuccessful
because it does not ultimately fulfill either of his two rules of revenge: “I must not only punish, but punish with impunity” and “the avenger [must] make himself felt as such to him who has done the wrong” (Poe 848).
What does Montresor admit is the motive for his revenge?
Montresor states that the motive for
his crime is revenge
. In his mind, he is the long-suffering innocent party who has suffered “the thousand injuries” of Fortunato with forbearance, but when “insult” follows, can endure Fortunato no longer.
What were Fortunato’s last words?
In “The Cask of Amontillado,” Fortunato’s last words to Montresor are “
For the love of God, Montresor!
” With these words, he’s begging for his life, trying desperately to make Montresor see that what he’s doing is completely wrong.
Why does Fortunato begin to laugh when he is being buried alive?
Fortunato is hoping against hope that he can somehow get Montresor to release him.
His laughter is forced
. He does not see anything funny about what has happened to him. It is horrible.
Does Montresor regret killing Fortunato?
Does Montresor regret killing Fortunato?
Montresor does not regret killing Fortunato
. On the contrary, even fifty years after he committed the deed, Montresor still thinks he was perfectly justified in murdering Fortunato.
Does Montresor feel guilty?
Throughout most of his evil deed against Fortunado,
Montresor does not demonstrate any sense of guilt or regret
. In fact, he seems to be rather enjoying himself and his diabolical plan. He teases Fortunado along, goading him and very cleverly manipulating the man to go further and further into the catacombs.
Does Montresor get his sweet revenge?
Expert Answers
Yes
, Montresor achieves exactly the kind of revenge he wants. He explains what he wants in the opening paragraph of the story, and by the end of the story he appears to be fully satisfied with what he has done.
